Seeking input...
I think I already know how few responses I'm likely to get to this, but I'll ask anyway...
I'm writing the third movement to my first symphony, and I'm stuck. I have a brilliant opening part but the second part (the Trio) leaves me a bit stumped. I come up with various "next part"s, but I'm never sure what sounds best... So I'm asking for advice.
Scherzo - Test #1
Scherzo - Test #2
The opening parts are the same in both, before anyone makes any comments to that effect. It's the last part. What works best? #1 or #2? If you can, please also try to say why you think the way you do?
The comments are screened so there's no cheating, too.
I'm writing the third movement to my first symphony, and I'm stuck. I have a brilliant opening part but the second part (the Trio) leaves me a bit stumped. I come up with various "next part"s, but I'm never sure what sounds best... So I'm asking for advice.
Scherzo - Test #1
Scherzo - Test #2
The opening parts are the same in both, before anyone makes any comments to that effect. It's the last part. What works best? #1 or #2? If you can, please also try to say why you think the way you do?
The comments are screened so there's no cheating, too.