"I saw you [verb]ing" (Japanese)

Feb 24, 2012 16:30

Hello! I've been lurking for a little while and this is my first post, so first I thought I would introduce myself briefly. ( Read more... )

syntax, asian languages, grammar, japanese

Leave a comment

akibare February 25 2012, 17:43:43 UTC
Yes, it works the same for any verb.

You need to take the sentences apart. As its_anya says too, "you can say that you saw it like any other noun..."

Your sentence, broken up, is:【【 あなたが踊っている】の】見た。

A verb takes an object (a noun, that you're "verbing") with を.
「Xを見た」="(I/he/she/they/Susan) saw X"
「Xを聞いた」="(I/he/she/they/Susan) heard X"
「Xを発見した」="(I/he/she/they/Susan) discovered X"

The X needs to be a noun. It can be a plain single noun like "car" or it can be a phrase that all together is a noun phrase.

「車を見た」="saw a car"
「車を聞いた」="heard a car"

The other important bit is that you can put の after a verb (の is like こと, and it is modified just like any other noun is, so the verb just hooks directly to it) to make the whole thing a noun phrase. The particles inside the phrase work like they would in a standalone sentence.

So, 「あなたが踊っている」="you are dancing" (action is ongoing)
「あなたが踊っているの」="(the fact/situation that) you are dancing" (action is ongoing)
It's 「あなたが」because あなた is the actor.

...and so all that is just the X in the various sentences above, the thing being seen.

「窓が割れているのを発見した」="(I/he/she/they/Susan) discovered that the window was broken"

「窓が割れている」="the window is broken" (it broke, and that situation of it having broken, is ongoing)
「窓が割れているの」="the situation/fact that the window is broken" (it broke, and that situation of it having broken, is ongoing)
Call that X, in the 「Xを発見した」above, and you see how the whole thing works out.

Reply

xlightbringerx February 26 2012, 15:43:37 UTC
Wow, this is great info. Thank you again!

Reply


Leave a comment

Up