Личная мягкая сила
Один профессиональный болтун написал недавно, что я слишком часто употребляю местоимение «я». Он, конечно, в данном случае прав. Записи в блоге если чем и связаны, то как раз личностью автора, так что, действительно, я про себя пишу больше, чем про что либо. И, наверное, больше чем нужно.
А тут у меня тут возникла идея измерить собственное "чисто интеллектуальное влияние" - собственную "мягкую силу". Случилось это так: в середине января я зашёл на диспут АНЦЭА двух представителей молодого поколения - Александра Либмана из ИЭ и Алексея Кузнецова из ИМЭМО о том, куда идёт российская экономическая наука. Там один из них сетовал, что наши учёные не публикуются по-английски, а другой - что результатами наших экономистов никто не интересуется...
Вот я взял и с помощью Гугла нашёл программы тех курсов в заграничных университетах, в которых в качестве обязательного или дополнительного чтения рекомендуются мои статьи. Что сразу удивляет - я почему-то думал, что только 2-3 статьи попадут в учебные программы, но попала, так или иначе, большая часть опубликованных статей.
Теперь вот думаю в целом - много получилось или мало? Есть хоть какое-то влияние или нет? Надо сказать, что программы многих курсов довольно быстро меняются (например, курсы про российскую политику), так что статьи десятилетней давности уже почти все выбыли из учебных курсов и с веб-сайтов (в частности, самая цитируемая моя статья не встречается в программах курсов). Однако интересно (и приятно), что наши статьи попали в пару десятков "классических" программ, которые читаются уже десятки лет (разного рода public choice и positive political economy). Интересен так же разброс - одна статья используется в курсах международных отношений. Впрочем, в новых, быстро развивающихся областях читать разные программы курсов ещё интереснее...
“Why Resource-Poor Dictators Allow Freer Media” (Сергей Гуриев, Георгий Егоров)
• Public Economics II, University of Alicante, 2013
•The Political Economy of China, Berkeley, 2008
• Development economics: Comparative institutional economics approach, EERC Kiev, 2007
• Comparative Authoritarianism, University of Oregon, 2010
• Authoritarianism, Berkeley, 2011
• The Political Economy of Natural Resources, University of Konstanz, 2012
• Mass Media and Politics, Southern Illinois University, 2013
• Collective Choice and Democracy, Ecole Polytechnique, France, 2012
• Topics in empirical political economy of government and development, Paris School of Economics, 2011
• Democracy and Authoritarianism, U. Colorado, 2010
• Comparative Political Institutions, Michigan State University, 2011
• Core Graduate Course in International Relations: Conflict, NYU, 2011 (Bruce Bueno de Mesquita!)
• Comparative Politics Survey, Columbia, 2012
• Topics in the Economics of Politics, University of Miami, 2012
• Politics and Media in Comparative Perspective, State University of Rio de Janeiro, 2013
• Political Change: Regime Transitions, Revolutions, Protests, SUNY-Buffalo, 2013
• Political Economy, University Pompeu Fabra, 2014
• Public Economics and Political Economy, SciencePo, 2014
• Politics under Authoritarianism, University of Florida, 2014
• Markets and Institutions, Stockholm School of Economics 2013
• Political Science Field Survey, Bocconi, 2014
• Government and Regulation, Stocholm School of Economics, 2014
• Democracy, UCSD, 2015
• Non-democratic Politics, University of Wisconsin-Madison, 2014
"Political Selection and Persistence of Bad Governments" (Дарон Асемоглу, Георгий Егоров)
• Foundations of Political Economy, Princeton, 2012 (Thomas Romer)
• Collective Choice and Democracy, Ecole Polytechnique, France, 2012
• Contract Theory and Applications, Wharton, UPenn
• Political Economy II, University of Rochester, 2011
• Public and Political Economics, Bavarian Graduate Program in Economics, 2012
• Foundations of Political Economy, Caltech, 2011
• Analysis of the Chinese Economy, CUHK, 2009
• Dynamic Political Economic Theory, Stanford, 2012
"Coalition Formation in Non-democracies"(Дарон Асемоглу, Георгий Егоров)
• Political Economy of Development, Columbia, 2010
• Institutions in Comparative Political Economy, PSU, 2011
• Political Economy of Development, Rochester, 2009
• Political Economy of Institutions and Development, MIT, 2012
• Comparative Political Institutions, Michigan State University, 2011
• Formal Models in International Relations, University of Wisconsin, 2012
• Game Theory, University of Wyoming, 2014
• Institutions in Economic Theory and Economic History, Heidelberg University, 2013
• Selected Topics in Development Economics, Universitat Siegen, 2014
• Political Economy of Economic Development, Harvard, 2015
• Non-democratic Politics, University of Wisconsin-Madison, 2014
"Dictators and their Viziers" (Георгий Егоров)
• Political Economy of Development, Columbia, 2010
• Comparative Political Institutions, University of Minnesota
• Political Economy of Development, University of Rochester, 2009
• Institutions in Comparative Political Economy, PSU, 2011
• Political Economy of Political Institutions, NYU, 2011
• New Institutional Economics, U. Massachusetts, Amherst, 2012
• Comparative Politics, NYU, 2005
• Comparative Political Institutions, Claremont Graduate University, 2011
• A Short Course on Political Economics, Central University of Finance and Economics, Beijing, 2009 (Roger Myerson)
• Topics in Positive Political Economy, Peking University, 2013
• Institutions in Economic Theory and Economic History, Heidelberg University, 2013
• Comparative Political Institutions, NYU
• Politics of Dictatorships, Binghamton, 2015
• Non-democratic Politics, University of Wisconsin-Madison, 2014
"Dynamics & Stability of Coalitions, Constitutions, and Clubs" (Дарон Асемоглу, Георгий Егоров)
• Political Economy of Institutions and Development, MIT, 2012
• Advanced Topics in Macroeconomics, U. Washington in St.Louis, 2013
• Political Economy II, Rochester, 2011
• Social Choice and Voting, Bocconi University, 2012
• Dynamic Political Economic Theory, Stanford, 2012
• Formal Models of Elections and Representation, Washington University, 2013
• Economics of Institutions, Norwegian School of Economics, 2014
• Formal Political Theory II, Harvard, 2014
• Social Choice and Voting Models, Northwestern, 2015
"A Theory of Brinkmanship, Conflict, and Commitment" (Майкл Шварц)
• Formal Models in International Relations, UCSD, 2004-11
• Theory and Methods in International Relations, Texas A & M, 2009
"Determinants of Nationalization in the Oil Sector" (Сергей Гуриев, Антон Колотилин)
• Analysis of the Transitional Economies, University of Washington, 2010
• Natural Resource Economics, UCSB, 2011
"Development Based on Commodity Revenues" (Сергей Гуриев, Александр Плеханов)
• Analysis of the Transitional Economies, University of Washington, 2010
• Post-Soviet States and Markets, Columbia, 2010
"Capture of Bankruptcy" (Екатерина Журавская, Ариана Ламберт-Могилянская)
• Business and Politics in Eastern and Central Europe, U. Rochester, 2010
• Aktuelle Forschungsfragen der russischen Volkswirtschaft (Topics in the Russian Economy), Frei University, Berlin, 2007
• The Former Socialist Economies and Transition, University of Pittsburgh, 2007
"Dictators and Oligarchs: A Dynamic Theory of Contested Property Rights" (Сергей Гуриев)
• Topics in Law and Economics, CEU, 2009
• Analytic Narratives: Research Methods in Economic History, Political Economy and Development, George Mason University
"Businessman Candidates" (Скотт Гельбах, Екатерина Журавская)
• Business and Politics in Eastern and Central Europe, U. Rochester, 2010
"A Political Theory of Populism" (Дарон Асемоглу, Георгий Егоров)
• Topics in Political Economy, University of Maryland, 2012 (Allan Drazen)
• Topics in Political Economy, Lombardy Advanced School in Economic Research, 2012 (Massimo Morelli)
• Political Economy of Institutions and Development, MIT, 2012
• Advanced Microeconomic Theory, Duke University, 2013
• Formal Political Theory II, Harvard University, 2014
• Formal Models of Elections and Representation, Washington University, 2013
"Incumbency Advantage in Non-Democracies" (Георгий Егоров)
• Comparative Elections and Voting, WKU, 2014
"Political Model of Social Evolution" (Дарон Асемоглу, Георгий Егоров)
• Approaches to Development, Carleton College, 2012
• Foundations of Political Economy, Princeton, 2012 (Thomas Romer)
"The Killing Game" (Георгий Егоров)
• Collective Choice and Democracy, Ecole Polytechnique, France, 2012
• A Short Course on Political Economics, Central University of Finance and Economics, Beijing, 2009 (Roger Myerson)
"Rational dictators and the killing of innocents: Data from Stalin's archives" (Пол Грегори, Филипп Шрёдер)
• Aktuelle Forschungsfragen der russischen Volkswirtschaft (Topics in the Russian Economy), Frei University, Berlin, 2012
• Economics of Non-market Decision Making, George Mason University, 2014
• Political Economy of Russia, Harvard, 2014
• Non-democratic Politics, University of Wisconsin-Madison, 2014
• Analytic Narratives: Research Methods in Economic History, Political Economy and Development, George Mason University
"Political Economy in a Changing World" (Дарон Асемоглу, Георгий Егоров)
• Macroeconomics II, Bogazici University
• Social Choice and Voting Models, Northwestern, 2015
"Do Juntas Lead to Personal Rule?" (Дарон Асемоглу, Георгий Егоров)
• Analysis of the Chinese Economy, CUHK, 2009
• Non-democratic Politics, University of Wisconsin-Madison, 2014
"Social Media and Corruption" (Рубен Ениколопов, Мария Петрова)
• Aktuelle Forschungsfragen der russischen Volkswirtschaft (Topics in the Russian Economy), Frei University, Berlin, 2012
• Information Communication Technology, Economic Development, and Political Violence, Princeton, 2014
"Government Control of the Media" (Скотт Гельбах)
• Public Economics II, University of Alicante, 2013
• Non-democratic Politics, University of Wisconsin-Madison, 2014
"Field Experiment Estimate of Electoral Fraud" (Алексей Захаров, Рубен Ениколопов, Василий Коровкин, Мария Петрова)
• Topics in Russian and Eurasian Studies: Political Economy of the Russian Transformation, University of Toronto, 2013
• Political Economy, University Pompeu Fabra, 2014
• Political Science: Election Forensics, University of Michigan, 2014
• Russian and Post-Soviet Politics, University of Wisconsin-Milwakee, 2014
• The Politics of Authoritarian Regimes, University of Wisconsin-Milwakee, 2013
• Introduction to Comparative Politics, UCLA, 2014
"Endogenous Property Rights" (Даниэль Дирмейер, Георгий Егоров)
• Comparative Political Economy, University of Konstanz, 2014
• Social Choice and Voting Models, Northwestern, 2015
"The End of Economic Transition"
• Economic Georgraphy, University of Southern Denmark, 2014
"Why the Rich May Favor Poor Protection of Property Rights"
• Economic Models of Politics, U.Chicago, 2006 (Roger Myerson)
• Economics of Transition, Berkeley, 200? (Gerard Roland)
"Collusive Market-Sharing and Corruption in Procurement" (Ариана Ламберт-Могилянски)
• Public Procurement in a Globalized World, Университет Лиссабона
Газетные колонки, выступления на круглых столах
• EU-Russia, Science Po, 2012
• Russian Government, Palacky University
А тут у меня тут возникла идея измерить собственное "чисто интеллектуальное влияние" - собственную "мягкую силу". Случилось это так: в середине января я зашёл на диспут АНЦЭА двух представителей молодого поколения - Александра Либмана из ИЭ и Алексея Кузнецова из ИМЭМО о том, куда идёт российская экономическая наука. Там один из них сетовал, что наши учёные не публикуются по-английски, а другой - что результатами наших экономистов никто не интересуется...
Вот я взял и с помощью Гугла нашёл программы тех курсов в заграничных университетах, в которых в качестве обязательного или дополнительного чтения рекомендуются мои статьи. Что сразу удивляет - я почему-то думал, что только 2-3 статьи попадут в учебные программы, но попала, так или иначе, большая часть опубликованных статей.
Теперь вот думаю в целом - много получилось или мало? Есть хоть какое-то влияние или нет? Надо сказать, что программы многих курсов довольно быстро меняются (например, курсы про российскую политику), так что статьи десятилетней давности уже почти все выбыли из учебных курсов и с веб-сайтов (в частности, самая цитируемая моя статья не встречается в программах курсов). Однако интересно (и приятно), что наши статьи попали в пару десятков "классических" программ, которые читаются уже десятки лет (разного рода public choice и positive political economy). Интересен так же разброс - одна статья используется в курсах международных отношений. Впрочем, в новых, быстро развивающихся областях читать разные программы курсов ещё интереснее...
“Why Resource-Poor Dictators Allow Freer Media” (Сергей Гуриев, Георгий Егоров)
• Public Economics II, University of Alicante, 2013
•The Political Economy of China, Berkeley, 2008
• Development economics: Comparative institutional economics approach, EERC Kiev, 2007
• Comparative Authoritarianism, University of Oregon, 2010
• Authoritarianism, Berkeley, 2011
• The Political Economy of Natural Resources, University of Konstanz, 2012
• Mass Media and Politics, Southern Illinois University, 2013
• Collective Choice and Democracy, Ecole Polytechnique, France, 2012
• Topics in empirical political economy of government and development, Paris School of Economics, 2011
• Democracy and Authoritarianism, U. Colorado, 2010
• Comparative Political Institutions, Michigan State University, 2011
• Core Graduate Course in International Relations: Conflict, NYU, 2011 (Bruce Bueno de Mesquita!)
• Comparative Politics Survey, Columbia, 2012
• Topics in the Economics of Politics, University of Miami, 2012
• Politics and Media in Comparative Perspective, State University of Rio de Janeiro, 2013
• Political Change: Regime Transitions, Revolutions, Protests, SUNY-Buffalo, 2013
• Political Economy, University Pompeu Fabra, 2014
• Public Economics and Political Economy, SciencePo, 2014
• Politics under Authoritarianism, University of Florida, 2014
• Markets and Institutions, Stockholm School of Economics 2013
• Political Science Field Survey, Bocconi, 2014
• Government and Regulation, Stocholm School of Economics, 2014
• Democracy, UCSD, 2015
• Non-democratic Politics, University of Wisconsin-Madison, 2014
"Political Selection and Persistence of Bad Governments" (Дарон Асемоглу, Георгий Егоров)
• Foundations of Political Economy, Princeton, 2012 (Thomas Romer)
• Collective Choice and Democracy, Ecole Polytechnique, France, 2012
• Contract Theory and Applications, Wharton, UPenn
• Political Economy II, University of Rochester, 2011
• Public and Political Economics, Bavarian Graduate Program in Economics, 2012
• Foundations of Political Economy, Caltech, 2011
• Analysis of the Chinese Economy, CUHK, 2009
• Dynamic Political Economic Theory, Stanford, 2012
"Coalition Formation in Non-democracies"(Дарон Асемоглу, Георгий Егоров)
• Political Economy of Development, Columbia, 2010
• Institutions in Comparative Political Economy, PSU, 2011
• Political Economy of Development, Rochester, 2009
• Political Economy of Institutions and Development, MIT, 2012
• Comparative Political Institutions, Michigan State University, 2011
• Formal Models in International Relations, University of Wisconsin, 2012
• Game Theory, University of Wyoming, 2014
• Institutions in Economic Theory and Economic History, Heidelberg University, 2013
• Selected Topics in Development Economics, Universitat Siegen, 2014
• Political Economy of Economic Development, Harvard, 2015
• Non-democratic Politics, University of Wisconsin-Madison, 2014
"Dictators and their Viziers" (Георгий Егоров)
• Political Economy of Development, Columbia, 2010
• Comparative Political Institutions, University of Minnesota
• Political Economy of Development, University of Rochester, 2009
• Institutions in Comparative Political Economy, PSU, 2011
• Political Economy of Political Institutions, NYU, 2011
• New Institutional Economics, U. Massachusetts, Amherst, 2012
• Comparative Politics, NYU, 2005
• Comparative Political Institutions, Claremont Graduate University, 2011
• A Short Course on Political Economics, Central University of Finance and Economics, Beijing, 2009 (Roger Myerson)
• Topics in Positive Political Economy, Peking University, 2013
• Institutions in Economic Theory and Economic History, Heidelberg University, 2013
• Comparative Political Institutions, NYU
• Politics of Dictatorships, Binghamton, 2015
• Non-democratic Politics, University of Wisconsin-Madison, 2014
"Dynamics & Stability of Coalitions, Constitutions, and Clubs" (Дарон Асемоглу, Георгий Егоров)
• Political Economy of Institutions and Development, MIT, 2012
• Advanced Topics in Macroeconomics, U. Washington in St.Louis, 2013
• Political Economy II, Rochester, 2011
• Social Choice and Voting, Bocconi University, 2012
• Dynamic Political Economic Theory, Stanford, 2012
• Formal Models of Elections and Representation, Washington University, 2013
• Economics of Institutions, Norwegian School of Economics, 2014
• Formal Political Theory II, Harvard, 2014
• Social Choice and Voting Models, Northwestern, 2015
"A Theory of Brinkmanship, Conflict, and Commitment" (Майкл Шварц)
• Formal Models in International Relations, UCSD, 2004-11
• Theory and Methods in International Relations, Texas A & M, 2009
"Determinants of Nationalization in the Oil Sector" (Сергей Гуриев, Антон Колотилин)
• Analysis of the Transitional Economies, University of Washington, 2010
• Natural Resource Economics, UCSB, 2011
"Development Based on Commodity Revenues" (Сергей Гуриев, Александр Плеханов)
• Analysis of the Transitional Economies, University of Washington, 2010
• Post-Soviet States and Markets, Columbia, 2010
"Capture of Bankruptcy" (Екатерина Журавская, Ариана Ламберт-Могилянская)
• Business and Politics in Eastern and Central Europe, U. Rochester, 2010
• Aktuelle Forschungsfragen der russischen Volkswirtschaft (Topics in the Russian Economy), Frei University, Berlin, 2007
• The Former Socialist Economies and Transition, University of Pittsburgh, 2007
"Dictators and Oligarchs: A Dynamic Theory of Contested Property Rights" (Сергей Гуриев)
• Topics in Law and Economics, CEU, 2009
• Analytic Narratives: Research Methods in Economic History, Political Economy and Development, George Mason University
"Businessman Candidates" (Скотт Гельбах, Екатерина Журавская)
• Business and Politics in Eastern and Central Europe, U. Rochester, 2010
"A Political Theory of Populism" (Дарон Асемоглу, Георгий Егоров)
• Topics in Political Economy, University of Maryland, 2012 (Allan Drazen)
• Topics in Political Economy, Lombardy Advanced School in Economic Research, 2012 (Massimo Morelli)
• Political Economy of Institutions and Development, MIT, 2012
• Advanced Microeconomic Theory, Duke University, 2013
• Formal Political Theory II, Harvard University, 2014
• Formal Models of Elections and Representation, Washington University, 2013
"Incumbency Advantage in Non-Democracies" (Георгий Егоров)
• Comparative Elections and Voting, WKU, 2014
"Political Model of Social Evolution" (Дарон Асемоглу, Георгий Егоров)
• Approaches to Development, Carleton College, 2012
• Foundations of Political Economy, Princeton, 2012 (Thomas Romer)
"The Killing Game" (Георгий Егоров)
• Collective Choice and Democracy, Ecole Polytechnique, France, 2012
• A Short Course on Political Economics, Central University of Finance and Economics, Beijing, 2009 (Roger Myerson)
"Rational dictators and the killing of innocents: Data from Stalin's archives" (Пол Грегори, Филипп Шрёдер)
• Aktuelle Forschungsfragen der russischen Volkswirtschaft (Topics in the Russian Economy), Frei University, Berlin, 2012
• Economics of Non-market Decision Making, George Mason University, 2014
• Political Economy of Russia, Harvard, 2014
• Non-democratic Politics, University of Wisconsin-Madison, 2014
• Analytic Narratives: Research Methods in Economic History, Political Economy and Development, George Mason University
"Political Economy in a Changing World" (Дарон Асемоглу, Георгий Егоров)
• Macroeconomics II, Bogazici University
• Social Choice and Voting Models, Northwestern, 2015
"Do Juntas Lead to Personal Rule?" (Дарон Асемоглу, Георгий Егоров)
• Analysis of the Chinese Economy, CUHK, 2009
• Non-democratic Politics, University of Wisconsin-Madison, 2014
"Social Media and Corruption" (Рубен Ениколопов, Мария Петрова)
• Aktuelle Forschungsfragen der russischen Volkswirtschaft (Topics in the Russian Economy), Frei University, Berlin, 2012
• Information Communication Technology, Economic Development, and Political Violence, Princeton, 2014
"Government Control of the Media" (Скотт Гельбах)
• Public Economics II, University of Alicante, 2013
• Non-democratic Politics, University of Wisconsin-Madison, 2014
"Field Experiment Estimate of Electoral Fraud" (Алексей Захаров, Рубен Ениколопов, Василий Коровкин, Мария Петрова)
• Topics in Russian and Eurasian Studies: Political Economy of the Russian Transformation, University of Toronto, 2013
• Political Economy, University Pompeu Fabra, 2014
• Political Science: Election Forensics, University of Michigan, 2014
• Russian and Post-Soviet Politics, University of Wisconsin-Milwakee, 2014
• The Politics of Authoritarian Regimes, University of Wisconsin-Milwakee, 2013
• Introduction to Comparative Politics, UCLA, 2014
"Endogenous Property Rights" (Даниэль Дирмейер, Георгий Егоров)
• Comparative Political Economy, University of Konstanz, 2014
• Social Choice and Voting Models, Northwestern, 2015
"The End of Economic Transition"
• Economic Georgraphy, University of Southern Denmark, 2014
"Why the Rich May Favor Poor Protection of Property Rights"
• Economic Models of Politics, U.Chicago, 2006 (Roger Myerson)
• Economics of Transition, Berkeley, 200? (Gerard Roland)
"Collusive Market-Sharing and Corruption in Procurement" (Ариана Ламберт-Могилянски)
• Public Procurement in a Globalized World, Университет Лиссабона
Газетные колонки, выступления на круглых столах
• EU-Russia, Science Po, 2012
• Russian Government, Palacky University