And winning by a landslide is my Sherlock/Torchwood fic, 'A Packet of Crisps and A Retcon Pill'. To be honest, I've always been surprised about how popular this fic is. With over 50 reviews in ff.net and 2 pages of feedback on LJ, this story's level of popularity leaves more bewildered that anything else. I honestly think I've written better stuff - a lot better! I guess its because of the humour and the punchline?
Other than that, I have to say my readership at AO3 is a lot more eclectic than at ff.net and LJ! A lot of the popular stuff is short and humorous but there are a few plotty fics there too! Also, can I say how pleased I am to see 'A lesson Learned' on this list? While I write Highlander's Amanda as someone whose life was greatly affected by Rebecca, I think this was the first time I gave them actual real 'screen time' together!
A Packet of Crisps and a Retcon Pill (Torchwood/Sherlock) - Gwen Cooper, Sherlock Holmes, Ensemble. Summary: Gwen has a mission to fulfill...if only she could remember what it was. Words: 1,295; Hits: 3320
Portally Yours (Dresden Files - Books/Doctor Who) Harry Blackstone Copperfield Dresden, Karrin Murphy, Mouse (dog), Tenth Doctor. Summary: It's amazing what you'll find down a dark alley... Words: 3,486 Hits: 674
A Vampire's Policy (Vampire Diaries (TV) ) - Elena Gilbert/Damon Salvatore, Stefan Salvatore, Ensemble. Summary: Stefan reignites his hunger for human blood, Elena tries to hold on as she deals with being turned, and Damon ensures he gets his own way... Spoilers through 1X22. Words: 43,321 Hits: 656
The First Time (Sherlock (TV)) - Sherlock Holmes, Mycroft Holmes. Summary: Sherlock was standing over the body when Mycroft arrived... Words: 512 Hits: 623
Timed out (Covert Affairs) - Auggie Anderson/Annie Walker. Summary: Have bomb, phone home... Words: 538 Hits: 477
Word Play (In Plain Sight) - Marshall Mann, Mary Shannon, Summary: Eleanor could not quite put her finger on the strangeness that was Mary and Marshall. It was like that time she caught them playing chess with the yahtzee dice... silly, cracky fic. Words: 1,464 Hits: 412
Hamlet's Ghost Methos, Duncan MacLeod, Joe Dawson, Amanda Darieux, Amy Thomas. Summary: Methos wakes up in the woods, with no memory of how he got there. (First story in my Methuselah's Secret series.) Words: 68,274 Hits: 286
A Lesson Learned by (Highlander: The Series, Highlander: The Raven) Amanda Darieux/Rebecca Horne, Amanda Darieux/Nick Wolfe, Father Liam, Joe Dawson, Methos. Summary: Because some lessons can't be learned by rote... Words: 3,702 Hits: 266
Favours Found Jack Harkness, Walter Bishop, Peter Bishop, Olivia Dunham, Astrid Farnsworth. Summary: Jack needs a favour from an old friend. Words: 2,664, Hits: 253
Are you dead or just glad to see me? ( Doctor Who, Highlander: The Series ) Martha Jones/Mickey Smith, Amanda Darieux, Methos. Summary: Another day at the office for Smith & Jones. Words: 897 Hits: 247