(Untitled)

Apr 05, 2007 17:39

Hi everyone -- I have something of an incomplete theory, and I'm looking for ideas/feedback ( Read more... )

Leave a comment

conuly April 5 2007, 22:14:56 UTC
Phineas was a Headmaster of Hogwarts, but that doesn't mean he was an especially important one. All headmasters have their portraits up after they die. Phineas is one of the few with another portrait elsewhere, yes - but that's housed in his family home, instead of in another institution. There's no reason to believe other people would have Dumbledore's picture - unless they collect chocolate frog cards, of course.

Reply

whatitistoburn1 April 5 2007, 23:01:10 UTC
I think that in OoTP Dumbledore explained to Harry that Phineas was an important headmaster of Hogwarts. I might be wrong, but I've been rereading it, and I'm pretty sure that's what caught my attention. [I believe it was when Arthur got attacked by the snake and Dumbledore asked Phineas to go tell Sirius that the Weasleys and Harry were coming to Grimmauld. Like I said, my books are 200 miles away and I might be wrong, but I'm pretty sure I remember that.]

I don't mean that other people would necessarily have his picture, I mean that he is important enough to have two portraits that he could walk through to and hear all of what's going on.

Reply

pstscrpt April 5 2007, 23:36:54 UTC
The only thing noteworthy I remember about Phineas Nigellus was that he was the least popular headmaster in Hogwarts history.

Reply

doctorrobotnik April 5 2007, 23:43:17 UTC
i think the only reason phineas had a portrait at grimmauld place was b/c he was related to the blacks, not b/c he was important or anything

Reply

conuly April 6 2007, 03:34:08 UTC
Exactly.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up