Film Discussion: Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows

[reallycorking]

With our final two movies, Deathly Hallows parts I & II, we wrap up our HP reunion film discussions. Thank you so much to everyone who participated in these posts--it's been a lot of fun seeing what you all loved and hated from the movies, and to relive some of the memorable scenes and moments with you all. You guys are awesome! So, without further

Comments

[reallycorking]

What do you think about how these films handled the many deaths that occurred? Which scenes made you the most sad?

[musicgoddess917]

Dobby and Hedwig. :< #fictionaldeathsIwillnevergetover

[shocolate]

Dobby.

ANd SNape actually mde me cry.

[allodole]

Freeeeeeeeeeeeeed ;_;

and Dobby and Hedwig but mostly just Fred because halksfskhlgd

[kate34books]

I'm still in denial over Hedwig, But I though her death scene in part 1 was Far better than what was in the book. If she had to die, I preferred it in her defending Harry than just being stuck in a cage and being accidentally hit with AK.

I did not expected to tear up at Mad eye's moody death, but I did.

Dobby was definitely sad. made worse by that little speech he gave before he died.

Fred Death Scene broke me. as soon as the music started playing I Knew it was coming and I was not ready for it.
I broke into sobs when George went to Hug Ron and Ron kneeled sobbing at his brother's body. (super acting on both the phelps and Rupert Grint)

Bellatrix & voldemort's death were weird and anti-climatic.

[sea_thoughts]

I think Hedwig's death was improved from the book. Wormtail's fate was a complete let down and as I said above, Voldemort's death was badly done. I felt like Fred and Remus and Tonks should have had more attention.