May 18, 2009 10:03
So, one of my reviewers pointed out that Phoenix song didn't really deserve an M/MA(NC17) rating and that I should lower it so that younger readers can read it too. I put it at that rating at the start because I wasn't really sure where it was going and thought it better to be safe than sorry. So, as someone more experienced with fanfic than I am, what would you rate it? (I guess the most rating-worthy bits are those in which it's mentioned or implied that HG is sexually active with VK, though there's no description, and then the fight with McLaggen . . . ?)
I guess I also don't want to disappoint someone who might read it thinking that it's more explicit than it actually is.
Your input is welcome here!