Half-Blood Prince Uberwank: Chapter 1, The Other Minister

Aug 29, 2008 15:15

Right, here we go then.

If you thought things had changed,
Friend, you'd better think again.
Bluntly put, in the fewest of words:
Cunts are still running the world.

- Jarvis Cocker, "Running the World"

Usual warnings apply: strong language (see above), ranting, politics, my thoughts on yaoi etc etc.

So. )

epic cats, hbp uberwank

Leave a comment

Comments 45

vickythefluffy August 29 2008, 15:18:39 UTC
Ok I haven't read it yet, I'm just a bit giddy at a.) not stumbling upon this several days late, and b.) you beginning it with JARVIS COCKER. Eeeeee! Ok, I'll write a proper comment momentarily; now to reeeeead...

Reply

vickythefluffy August 29 2008, 15:38:19 UTC
TOP NOTCH. First off, I totally agree about JKR being awdully crud at furst chapters. Either she does that "WHOAAA HARRY POTTER IS MAGIC!" thing, as you say, or she just makes them painfully dull and slightly irrelevent. I mean, I don't think I've ever read the first chapter of Goblet of Fire in full; it was too boring.

Secondly, I LOLed at a lot, but I particularly enjoyed if I have to hear the phrase "Are you fucking serious?" "Did last night, LOL" one more time I am going to go crazy with a hammer in a shopping centre and Well, at least she's allowed Ron to move on from making "Uranus" jokesThird point! I can totally see Kingsley with a Mean-Girls-style business card with his name and underneath: "Professional badass ( ... )

Reply

fera_festiva August 30 2008, 09:17:57 UTC
*Bounces* Thank you darlin'!

I don't think I've ever read the first chapter of Goblet of Fire in full; it was too boring

It's funny you say that, because that's the only one I can think of that does have any action in it. I remember feeling oddly shocked that it wasn't from Harry's POV when I read it. I do see what you mean, though, now I think of it - it's about an old man taking half an hour to walk up the stairs, isn't it? :D

my brother applied for MI5

Won't he have to kill you now you've told me that? And me. And everyone who might read... my god. What have you done.

Reply

vickythefluffy August 30 2008, 19:07:29 UTC
I don't know about that first chapter... I appreciated the OOH PLOTTING rather than the LOL IM MAGIC, but yeah, I didn't entirely care for the trundling old fool that replaced... well, the slightly-younger fool.

LOL, whoops. He's too stupid to get in anyway, I doubt it matters. Plus, I doubt that he'd get hunted down by your band of "angry loners", not even if his spy-code-name-thing was like siblingthefluffy or something preposterous like that.

Reply


mushroom18 August 29 2008, 15:55:45 UTC
It would be interesting if the Prime Minister knew nothing at all, and there was a secret muggle society that knew...you know like a Section Nine unit or something.

Again, I know this isn't real life because in real life, the PM would probably just declare war on all wizards, choosing to ignore the fact that the attacks we've heard about were perpetrated by a very tiny, marginalised and radicalised group who in no way represent the larger population to which they belong.

That's EXACTLY what I had in mind! Or maybe they're just scared?

Reply

fera_festiva August 30 2008, 09:38:11 UTC
It would be interesting if the Prime Minister knew nothing at all, and there was a secret muggle society that knew

You see, that would be badass, and would lead to some potentially really interesting crossovers and spinoffs. Or there is one already and it's Torchwood I agree though, it just seems a bit simplistic to have only the PM knowing anything - and in the UK system the PM can't make decisions about anything without the backing of parliament and blah blah blah so it seems a little pointless too.

Or maybe they're just scared?

Perhaps, but fear leads to the Dark Side of the Force...

Reply


myworldmytrue August 29 2008, 16:05:43 UTC
Quoting JARVIS! <3

Now all I can see is Fudge bursting into the PMs office, yelling "Sirius Black has escaped! GAY PORN alert!", at which point everybody promptly panics. :D Oh, good times!

Nicely done, this, even with the boring chapter and all. And you know, political scandals should involve gas masks and bumming rentboys much more than they currently do. Although, I have to say, American politicians/mayors etc have fared rather admirably on this front...*grin*

Reply

fera_festiva August 30 2008, 09:53:31 UTC
This is another time I wish I had a Jarvis icon. Oh, Jarvis, how I love you. *daydreams*

"Sirius Black has escaped! GAY PORN alert!"

OMFG I LOL'd. "Prime Minister, let's not be too rash! The fangirls have power we can only imagine!"

American politicians/mayors etc have fared rather admirably on this front

Heh. There needs to be a graph of US politics, showing - for example - homophobic bigotry correlated with likelihood of being caught sucking a rentboy's cock. :D

Reply

spacefragments August 31 2008, 17:29:35 UTC
"Sirius Black has escaped! GAY PORN alert!" should be an icon. just sayin'.

Reply


lefaym August 29 2008, 18:49:19 UTC
In my mind, Rowling's PM will always be Jim Hacker.

And the DW (and spinoffs) approach to unbelievable events actually always struck me as pretty similar to Rowling's-- both rely on most people being so utterly boring that they will come up with outlandish explanations to avoid having to believe in aliens/magic, and for the people who don't, there's always retcon/obliviate.

Reply

fera_festiva August 30 2008, 10:44:01 UTC
In my mind, Rowling's PM will always be Jim Hacker

OMFG, yes! (Although I admit I've always enjoyed the idea that it's the PM from Little Britain - and I don't even like that show much. I just wish this PM was female so she could be Harriet Jones.)

I agree about the ordinary-people-not-noticing thing as well - and actually I think DW normally does it pretty well. (I always appreciate the thing in the new series where there are nerds who follow the Doctor obsessively, like that guy in Blink.) It's more than in DW it's got to the point where - well, how could the general population not notice what went on in the most recent season finale? Which is fine, it just means the show is taking place in a slightly alternative version of contemporary Britain.

Reply

lefaym August 30 2008, 11:14:44 UTC
Well, the show has been in a slightly AU contemporary Britain from the first Season of New Who anyway-- because even though people are denying the existance of aliens, they're still reacting to things like the destruction of Big Ben, the Sycorax invasion etc-- they're just denying the cause of it. And their social, economic and political framework appears to be remarkably resisilent, given that it can survive the almost complete destruction of two British governments, the depostion of another PM in between the two, and the assassination of a US president ( ... )

Reply

fera_festiva August 31 2008, 20:25:05 UTC
If she was the Muggle PM she would already have an ubercool secret weapon ready for just this eventuality, and she'd blast Voldemort and all his horcruxes into oblivion using alien technology.

LOL! I would pay good money to see that. I'd hope she'd use that green death-ray thing from the Sycorax episode (if nothing else, because it resembles the ray from the Death Star). :D

OMG, so someone needs to write an AU where Torchwood hunt down the horcruxes. (They wouldn't spend too much time messing around in a tent, I don't reckon. They'd ride right up to, say, Malfoy Manor in the SUV, shoot down the magic gates, immobilise everyone with some kind of alien weapon - probably there'd be a couple of casualties, like Greyback or someone - and just GTFO. Gwen might cry, to provide the human angle. Also Jack WOULD get AKd.) And then a sequel where the DEs get hold of the Risen Mitten!

Not that I've thought about it. Or anything. Ahem.

Reply


cristiline August 29 2008, 21:31:38 UTC
Aw, Fudge is adorable!

Again, I know this isn't real life because in real life, the PM would probably just declare war on all wizards, choosing to ignore the fact that the attacks we've heard about were perpetrated by a very tiny, marginalised and radicalised group who in no way represent the larger population to which they belong.
I don't think the PM knows how many wizards there are, though. He could be under the impression that there are just as many wizards as there are Muggles or something. I got the impression that he wants to know as little about the wizarding world as possible.

You know, the main thing that jumps out at me from this chapter (all the exposition aside) is the implication that only the Prime Minister is aware of the Ministry of Magic, wizards in general in fact, and has little or no contact with anyone other than the minister himself.Well I suppose other world leaders would know. But I can't really see the American president just keeping that a secret. Now he's someone who'd declare war on them. But I suppose ( ... )

Reply

fera_festiva August 30 2008, 18:39:44 UTC
Fudge is totally adorable. She is a wicked cat and completely insane. *snuggles kitteh*

I don't think the PM knows how many wizards there are, though

Yeah, that was just me being a bit facetious and ranty about, well, the Iraq war.

Well it is a logical mistake to make.

Is it, though? I dunno, maybe I'm just biased because I'm so, so sick of hearing it, but it doesn't strike me as logical because "Serious" isn't a name. And there is a subtle pronunciation difference. It's not so much that I'd expect him to recognise "Sirius" as a name, but that I don't think it is a logical error. But IDK. *shrugs*

Reply


Leave a comment

Up