I've been waiting to see Orpheus come up on this! It's one of my all-time favorite episodes of Angel. So mind-bendy!
One of my favorite Buffy-verse writers is
talesofspike. Sadly she's moved on to other fandoms, but her
In the Underworld is probably my favorite Orpheus fic. And one of my favorite AtS fics! In this version Wesley's along for the ride, and we get to experience Faith and Wes' tragic, screwed up lives too. It's dark but meaty. So much love for this fic!
warning: this one's a little dark. And there's (fairly non-explicit) non-con in a later chapter
In the Underworld chapter 1,
chapter 2,
chapter 3,
chapter 4 mods: first post to this com. Let me know if I did this wrong!