Can't fight an Eclipse.

Aug 09, 2007 17:22

Review of Eclipse

At first I decided that I would have lots quotes, but frankly I don't have time for that at the moment.
Long,loooong entry, I don't think i've ever been that invested in writing a review of fandom before! )

eclipse, review

Leave a comment

usedtobending August 10 2007, 04:13:15 UTC
I thought Jacob was tolerable, until the last few chapters...he really got to me. Both him and Bella actually. Every time I read a pro-Jacob review it makes me angrier and my dislike hate grows lol.

I would really be interested in witnessing (not partaking) in a good Edward vs Jacob debate. A lot of the Jacob reviews seem pretty solid, but they tend to ignore the morals and ethics of what's acceptable in civil society lol. I think fangirling aside, a lot of Edward fans have very good arguments why Edward > Jacob.

That does suck that you don't feel comfortable in your own journal, it's hard to ignore that. That's why I'm ignoring most twilight communities right now lol. I just wish they would admit that Jacob was shady and manipulative and Bella was selfish--and if they say they don't care and they still love him it makes me feel less guilty for wanting to slap them (jk) ;)

I don't mind at all! I kind of wanted to add you in the past but I was kind of scared *hides* I didn't really review the book in my journal though, but I'll help you fight off the Jacob fans :D

Reply


Leave a comment

Up