Who would make a great judge (or guest judge)?
Michael Johns -- 6%
Constantine Maroulis -- 22%
Carly Smithson -- 19%
Diana DeGarmo -- 2%
Clay Aiken -- 47%
Taylor Hicks -- 4%
VOTE!! Think about it...Carly and Simon, in the same room again.
IT WOULD BE THE RETURN OF
THE T-SHIRT.