FTD: Yoshitoki Kuninobu vs Shuuya Nanahara

[anbyrobanby]

Chelovek Cheloveku Brat! :O

http://community.livejournal.com/br_roleplay/708288.html?mode=reply

A FTD is up!

Yoshitoki Kuninobu vs Shuuya Nanahara

Who wins? Who dies?

The time is 8:19am GMT. 24 hours, comments screened, etc etc.

Good luck to the both of you!

Comments

Yoshitoki

[schalein]

YEEEEESH. This is honestly one of the closest. votes. ever. In my opinion, at least. At first glance it seems almost obvious that Shuuya should win, but...after thinking things over, I'm not too sure. So I'ma just go over my thoughts and see what happens.

Shuuya has been great all version. Very consistent, very... Very, well, Shuuya. He's exactly the same Shuuya as the one in the novel and, even though there are a lot of similarities to Manga Shuuya, I don't really mind. Gabby has handled him brilliantly.

Nobu got off to a bit of a slow start. The team-up with Yutaka and Yuka didn't go as well as planned, maybe? I dunno'. He definitely picked up pace at an incredible speed, though. Around the time he killed off Oda. At that point we started to see a huge shift in his character, and, y'know, I really felt for him. I can understand where all his insecurities are coming from, they're beautiful and they're real.

So, um. The way I see it, both peeps have incredible writing ability. I'd say nearly equal. Shuuya has definitely been much more consistent this version, but, at the same time, I think we've seen more development from Yoshitoki. He went through a believable -if not a little heart-breaking- shift of character and I kind of love him for that. So yeah, by like, a hair, my vote goes to Yoshitoki Kuninobu.

Good luck! ♥