FTD: Yoshitoki Kuninobu vs Shuuya Nanahara

[anbyrobanby]

Chelovek Cheloveku Brat! :O

http://community.livejournal.com/br_roleplay/708288.html?mode=reply

A FTD is up!

Yoshitoki Kuninobu vs Shuuya Nanahara

Who wins? Who dies?

The time is 8:19am GMT. 24 hours, comments screened, etc etc.

Good luck to the both of you!

Comments

Shuuya to win...

[theonlyjosh]

I found myself really understanding everything he was feeling and when it got to the point of knowing Noriko was dead and Yoshi started to play I thought it was logical enough. I'm not sure if the actual killing of Oda was too my liking (although unique XD) but finding Shuuya was the biggest step in personality. Even though the stuff with Yuka/Yutaka was a bit disjointed Lili managed to get past that and I think it worked well up to Shuuya of Yoshi being by himself.

The highlight of Yoshi again is the argument. Seriously, I just could get everything Yoshi meant and it felt that when I was reading it I actually wanted to stick up for him because I understood his anger at Shuuya. All the emotions and actions just seemed right and I praise Lili a lot for this and think her and Gabby work well together. <3

Okay, I got to now bring this to a conclusion. D: This seems to be a scenario of head vs heart and I just don't want either of them to go. Shuuya extends in characterisation with background but I think just slightly Yoshi does in personality as I can understand him better. Both are excellant writers but I slightly prefer Lili's to Gabby's although in dialogue it have to be equal. It would be obvious now that perhaps Yoshi is becoming my choice but I eventually decided that I want Shuuya to win.
This is because of the dedication, the quality and quantity of work Gabby's put into Shuuya and Just because he is a great character. I hardly have any faults for either character though and I probably going to be pondering over this but this is inevitably my decision. :P

Good luck to you both. <3