Menstruation Is Fast Becoming Optional

May 22, 2006 09:51

By LINDA A. JOHNSON, Associated Press Writer ( Read more... )

contraception, menstruation, sex, women

Leave a comment

Comments 38

malkin767 May 22 2006, 14:56:14 UTC
I think this report misses one major positive of having a period: the assurance that one isn't pregnant!

Reply

deathjoy May 22 2006, 15:10:05 UTC
I've been stacking for years and I would much rather take an at home pregnancy test every month. Pee on a strip or bleed for days? I'll choose the former:)

Reply

malkin767 May 22 2006, 15:42:19 UTC
True, but a monthly pregnancy test isn't affordable for everyone.

Reply

Speaking just as a chick, not an anthro person at the moment _boneflower_ May 22 2006, 16:20:42 UTC
Much as I dislike getting my period, I was more distressed when I was put on BC to skip it for a three month trip overseas. I hadn't even had sex, and I was still climbing the walls.

A pregnancy test may not cost much, but cramps = instant, free peace of mind for me. By the time I would be taking a pregnancy test, it would have already totally foobared my month.

I wonder if I would get used to it, or just flip out every month?

Reply


twilight2000 May 22 2006, 15:02:59 UTC
I have to wonder what the long term effect on eggs and thus on birth defects will be. I understand the positive implications for this one, but what does this do to the age of the eggs? Do they sluff regularly or does production stop and you end up with old eggs at the head of the line?

Reply

stelli May 22 2006, 15:09:45 UTC
Given that you are born with all the eggs you ever have, I don't think it would make a difference.

Reply

malkin767 May 22 2006, 15:33:57 UTC
Actually, scientists aren't so sure anymore that that's the case.

Reply

dyheli May 22 2006, 20:01:20 UTC
I was really excited and looking forward to reading this article but when I get a couple of paragraphs down I'm hit with: "To continue reading this article, subscribe to New Scientist. Get 4 issues of New Scientist magazine and instant access to all online content for only USD $4.95."

Any way you could post this article to the community in full text? I could probably access is through my school's online journal system, but I'm short on time.

Thanks!

Reply


aaangyl May 22 2006, 15:27:29 UTC
I wonder about weight gain - there seems to be some at least ancedotal clustering of weight gain with not having a period - 30-50% side effect on the most common period-stoppers like depo & stacked minipill. Would there be any logical biochemical basis for not bleeding leading to weight gain?

Reply

tytal May 22 2006, 20:50:49 UTC
It's not the lack of a period that causes the weight gain. Most women have a small, but transient, weight gain when first starting OBC or any hormonal therapies. It's due to the change in hormone levels; they usually change your hunger levels and, for some, activity levels.

My younger sister does the same thing to avoid her period and when she noticed a little gain, she modified her exercise routine.

Speaking as a man, I don't think I'd be able to put up with a constant nusiance like a period. And you can bet there wouldn't be any nonchalant ''Oh, I'm just on my period'' garbage. If I'm bleeding, something better be cut. I say if you want to halt your periods, go ahead. It's your body.

Reply


deadkytty9 May 22 2006, 15:36:26 UTC
I tried that with the Nuvaring. It made me even more depressed than just taking the pill did. To be fair, every body responds differently (and I know a lot of women for whom it's a huge blessing), but I'm most definitely not a fan.

Reply

malkin767 May 22 2006, 15:41:25 UTC
Nuvaring made me slowly go insane over a number of years. By the end, I started having panic attacks when the pizza man would ring the doorbell. I just couldn't handle the hormones in Nuvaring, I guess.

Reply

deadkytty9 May 22 2006, 15:47:26 UTC
Yup. Sounds just like me. Yasmin did the same thing, to a much lesser degree, which is odd, considering the actual amounts of the hormones in the bloodstream are much lower and more constant in Nuvaring. Hormones do really odd things sometimes.

Reply

jopasm May 22 2006, 16:27:37 UTC
There's a couple of quotes in the article that make me wonder if some effects aren't heightened by birth control ( ... )

Reply


just want to voice this metahara May 22 2006, 16:51:38 UTC
i love my period and will miss it after menopause.

I have easy periods that last 2 or 3 days 4 the most. I feel no pain, just a congestion followed by release. I feel a little more sleepy, almost drugged like feeling from the hormone change. I am most creative as an artist and my cooking excels during my moon time.

I've always practiced Yoga and am told that along with certain belly dance techniques are the reason i feel comfortable rather than in pain during menses.

I have no idea what women who feel pain go thru, but, i'm sure i would want it to stop if i felt pain.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up