"When you wake up, you'll have a mom and dad. And you won't even remember me."

Oct 08, 2012 03:58

Went and changed the layout - anna_sg1. Twice in one year, very unlike me but the last one was just too bright ugh.

I've seen some comments on tumblr and I have questions for my Doctor Who loving (or just Doctor Who watching XD) friends - did the events in the whole of season 5 even happen after that Big Bang or whatever that was? I now that Amy, Rory, Eleven and River remember all of it happening, and by that I mean all the events from the episodes (don't ask me why they remember, we'll ignore that for now)

BUT

after Amy ~remembers~ everything, she gets her parents back from the start, and they never go missing this time around. She doesn't share fish fingers and custard with the Doctor because NOW Amelia has parents in the house. And she then doesn't go outside to wait for him. Or does she?

So. When Amy in TATM writes to Eleven to go tell little Amelia that's waiting for him all the adventures she'll have... there should be no little Amelia there.

Or am I getting all the events in season 5 finale wrong?

Even Amy in one of those DVD extra mini-episodes says that she remembers two different lives and that it's weird. So team Tardis remembers it - but it didn't happen. Not after the Big Bang, right?

Help?

flist, doctor who, meta, weirdness, lj stuff, random, season 5

Previous post Next post
Up