Top 7 Review
So it's official David Cook has finally surpassed Carly as my #1 favourite. That's okay, she's still a very close #2 and they are two of my favourite AI contestants ever. I've never loved a male contestant on AI this much before. David C ftw!
Archuleta singing that song from Prince of Egypt
I don't know if I posted it here but I actually predicted a week or two ago that Archie would sing this and dedicate it to more disenfranchised people. It was almost barf enducing. I can't stand the sight or the sound of him or his fangirls anymore. I have no further comment.
Carly singing "Without You"
I liked it and felt Simon was once again too harsh on her. She's obviously not a chosen one anymore. It's like she tries and she tries but for Simon nothing is good enough because her last name isn't Archuleta and 12 year old girls won't have any interest in purchasing a CD for her. It's a shame her VISA fell through two years ago when Archie was too young to be on the show.
Syesha singing "Vanishing"
Nice song but there were way too many parts that were painful to listen to. Good thing the judges gave her good commentary though, after last week I'm sure she was ready to cut them if they had dared say anything negative.
Brooke singing "Hero"
I think I would have preferred it with a guitar. Honestly though Brooke was easily the worst. She does not have the vocal skill to have done anything of Mariah's justice, especially if she wasn't going to even change it up that much. She didn't go for big glory notes and she still didn't sound good.
Kristy Lee singing "Forever"
Looks like she's overstayed her welcome a bit too long for Simon. She was excellent and I'm glad Paula had the balls to tell her the truth when Randy and Simon were feeding her bull********. She did a great job and she handled a week that definitely wasn't in her favour perfectly.
David C singing "Always Be My Baby"
I was a little worried about this week's theme for DC but he pulled it out. Best of the night by far and he did a wonderful rendition of one of the few Mariah songs I actually know and like. I was very impressed. I love this guy and I hope he wins. His brother is probably so proud of him, the look on his face after getting to watch his little brother put a smile on my face.
Jason singing something I forget the name of
It was decent but definitely not a great vocal. He really didn't deserve as much praise as he got for it.
I want to have DCook's babies.
Archuleta singing that song from Prince of Egypt
I don't know if I posted it here but I actually predicted a week or two ago that Archie would sing this and dedicate it to more disenfranchised people. It was almost barf enducing. I can't stand the sight or the sound of him or his fangirls anymore. I have no further comment.
Carly singing "Without You"
I liked it and felt Simon was once again too harsh on her. She's obviously not a chosen one anymore. It's like she tries and she tries but for Simon nothing is good enough because her last name isn't Archuleta and 12 year old girls won't have any interest in purchasing a CD for her. It's a shame her VISA fell through two years ago when Archie was too young to be on the show.
Syesha singing "Vanishing"
Nice song but there were way too many parts that were painful to listen to. Good thing the judges gave her good commentary though, after last week I'm sure she was ready to cut them if they had dared say anything negative.
Brooke singing "Hero"
I think I would have preferred it with a guitar. Honestly though Brooke was easily the worst. She does not have the vocal skill to have done anything of Mariah's justice, especially if she wasn't going to even change it up that much. She didn't go for big glory notes and she still didn't sound good.
Kristy Lee singing "Forever"
Looks like she's overstayed her welcome a bit too long for Simon. She was excellent and I'm glad Paula had the balls to tell her the truth when Randy and Simon were feeding her bull********. She did a great job and she handled a week that definitely wasn't in her favour perfectly.
David C singing "Always Be My Baby"
I was a little worried about this week's theme for DC but he pulled it out. Best of the night by far and he did a wonderful rendition of one of the few Mariah songs I actually know and like. I was very impressed. I love this guy and I hope he wins. His brother is probably so proud of him, the look on his face after getting to watch his little brother put a smile on my face.
Jason singing something I forget the name of
It was decent but definitely not a great vocal. He really didn't deserve as much praise as he got for it.
I want to have DCook's babies.