Tag Set reopened

Oct 04, 2013 13:40

The tag set has been reopened for vetting. As it was unclear which problems should go in the form, the form will remain closed and all problems should be noted in the comments of this post ( Read more... )

admin, tag set review

Leave a comment

rekallthegreat October 4 2013, 23:04:47 UTC
The lists should probably be broken up like this.

Ultimate Spider-Man
Aaron Davis (Ultimates)
Ganke Lee (Ults)
Gwen Stacy (Ults)
Jefferson Davis (Ultimates)
Jessica Drew (Ultimates)
Johnny Storm (Ultimates)
Judge (Ultimates)
Kate Bishop (Ultimates)
Maria Hill (Ultimates)
Mary Jane Watson (Ultimates)
May Parker (Ultimates)
Miles Morales (Ultimates)
Rio Morales (Ultimates)
Tandy Bowen (Ultimates)
Tyrone "Ty " Johnson (Ultimates)

Marvel Ultimates
Monica Chang (Ultimates)
Pietro Maximoff (Ultimateverse)
Sam Wilson (Ultimates)
Susan Storm (Ultimates)
Wanda Maximoff (Ultimateverse)
Carol Danvers (Ultimates)
Janet Pym (Ultimates)

Johnny Storm is the only one I'm not entirely sure of. Looking at his list of appearances though ( http://marvel.wikia.com/Category:Jonathan_Storm_%28Earth-1610%29/Appearances ) he is in Ultimate Spider-Man quite a bit.

Reply

boxlawyer October 4 2013, 23:45:45 UTC
One way to solve the Johnny Storm issue might be to just put him into both categories and disambiguate him? It's a bit late now to try and find the nominator(s) and find out what they intended, given that signups are meant to be in a few days, and so the additional tag while undesirable would solve the issue as to which series he belongs in.

Reply

musesfool October 5 2013, 01:45:49 UTC
+1

I agree with this break out, and also agree that Johnny should be in Utimate Spider-man, since he spends quite a number of issues living with Peter and Aunt May (and also that is how he was listed last year, when Ultimate Spider-man was correctly separated from Ultimates, and I matched on Peter & Johnny).

Reply


Leave a comment

Up