Comments | twopointohno: Round 1 ch 8 Final Voting

iulieki in twopointohno

Round 1 ch 8 Final Voting - Monk

Jun 02, 2008 22:32

Please vote for the one set you feel displays the least quality in terms of technique and skill. Check out this excellent guide to voting objectively in LIMS. Comments that show personal preference will not be counted. Please do not use "like" statements and please be objective in your voting. This means no "I don't like Marcelle Script and ( Read more... )

voting, round 1

Comments 2

anonymous June 4 2008, 03:51:14 UTC

iulieki June 4 2008, 04:24:41 UTC

Sorry, I think the voting format is confusing you. This LIMS is different in that each contestant submits a set of five icons.

So in voting, you should pick a least favorite set (either set 1 or set 2). and then give a reason why they are of lesser quality, using the letters (A B C D E) to describe specific icons within the set. Reasons should focus on technical aspects of the icons, rather than personal tastes and style.

Hope that clears things up! You can resubmit your vote in another comment if you like.

anonymous June 5 2008, 16:53:11 UTC

iulieki June 6 2008, 20:27:15 UTC

hehe totally not necessary to say nice things about your favorite this time, but still very much appreciated!

I think your comments about text are relevant, as the wrong text can really ruin an icon.