Leave a comment

Comments 49

ethereal_dusky September 1 2010, 22:03:02 UTC
I do wish SM would just shut up about her dislike for Edward, we get it, you hate the guy.

It's like she's punishing Team Edward for not liking Jacob so she is trying to force her opinions on us in a way that says 'I'm right, your wrong, get off Edward's dick and suck Jacob's'

Reply

denoftrolls September 1 2010, 22:20:34 UTC
ikr it kind of irritates me that she's so rude about him. Why didn't she just make Bella end up with Jacob if she loves him so much

Reply

kagokadae September 2 2010, 12:10:07 UTC
god then i will hate the books ... lol..maybe she did .. but the publishers said NO WAY to jacob! if you want your books to sell big..lol

Reply

peggababy September 2 2010, 01:37:49 UTC
I do wish SM would just shut up about her dislike for Edward, we get it, you hate the guy.

I agree. The more she talks the more respect I loose for her. At this point I wonder why she even let Edward and Bella end up together if she "loves' Jacob so damn much. I could understand if she wrote him to be interesting, but he isn't. He is just plain dull boring, uneducated teenager that never really grows up and learns from his mistakes.

Reply


morganw10 September 1 2010, 22:07:52 UTC
What SMeyer says doesn't change how much I love Edward and Bella it just makes me hate her. She is ruining the couple. I don't understand why she seems to dislike them so much now but she does.

The movies aren't as good as the books but when are movie adaptations ever as good as the books? I think they change too many of the characters personalities in the movies. Where's Edward's humor? Or Jacob's mean side? We've barely seen any of those two.

If I could change one thing about the movies I would change the screenwriter. Obvious choice right? LOL. Melissa has got to go. She is atrocious.

Reply

nouveauyou September 2 2010, 08:10:27 UTC
IAWTC ... all of it.

Reply

kagokadae September 2 2010, 12:16:20 UTC
^^ i so agreed with ya :D
god how did we ended up with loving the characters and disliking the author?!LOL
i don't think i dislike her ... but i don't like that she putting edward down ..

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

thy_chiaroscuro September 2 2010, 03:55:35 UTC
"Does what SMeyer have to say effect how you feel about the books and movies?
No, why would it? She's a person like anyone else and the only opinion that matters to me in the long run is my own."

look at you being all reasonable and objective. ♥♥♥

Reply


cptlbryant September 1 2010, 22:15:17 UTC
I, frankly, don't like SMeyer. Something about her has always bothered me. I find her annoying. Which means I don't watch interviews with her and really if she comes on TV or a see an article about her, I skip by it ( ... )

Reply

chell143 September 1 2010, 22:16:43 UTC
I agree with the Breaking Dawn change. Re-write.

Reply

kagokadae September 2 2010, 12:21:15 UTC
i agreed about book bella and movie bella .. i was kinda disliking book bella, at times, i want to give her a good smack ..lol.. how she is acting, hurting edward ... and whining about jacob really annoys the hell out of me ...
i do like breaking dawn though, not everything, but overall, i guess i am ok.
I do wish that for less jacob, and no imprinting on nesse, i wished it was a boy if there must be a baby ...

Reply


chell143 September 1 2010, 22:18:38 UTC
Stephenie has no affect on me when it comes to books or movies. I just wish she wouldn't put Edward down so much while lifting Jacob up ( ... )

Reply

shalia74 September 1 2010, 22:22:29 UTC
I agree with pretty much everything you said.

Books adaptation are most often not as good as we hope. In these, some things they made better, some worse.

As for SMeyer, it's like since we didn't all start gushing over Jacob like her (or BD), then she's lifting him up and putting Edward down.

Reply

chell143 September 1 2010, 22:30:06 UTC
was it you that like the fic, distractions too?

Reply

shalia74 September 1 2010, 23:01:04 UTC
yes :)

Reply


Leave a comment

Up