it's a nice day to start again

[laeria]

Flist o flist!

I have a question for you! Which may or may not be born from my vague Balkanic annoyance with the Willian/Kate craze (not the actual people, but the craze, it has infected my television in a way that keeps baffling).

What makes a good fictional wedding?
I can think of some weddings I've read/watched, but generally they ended with

Comments

[penny_lane_42]

and then fuck up a whole very important storyline by having the character omit a crucial "yes" in a crucial moment? WHY HBO WHY.

Oooh! I haven't had a chance to watch the whole thing through yet. Does this have to do with Dany, though? Because I heard some iffy stuff re: that. Hopefully I'll get to watch tomorrow.

Weddings! Favorite wedding ever: the one that just happened on Parks and Recreation. What should have been ridiculous and silly managed to be heartwarming and silly. I loved it.

I am also fond of Will and Elizabeth getting married in the middle of battle in whichever Pirates movie that is.

But other than that, yeah, I can't really think of one that works for me? I'll have to ponder this and then get back to you.

[laeria]

Yes, it does have to do with Dany. And they were doing so well too, up until the actual wedding scene. And and and, it's very frustrating, because I can very literally think of NO GOOD REASON for them to change her story like that. Except the one in my icon, I suppose

[thornyrose42]

Oh I'd forgotten about Will and Elizabeth. But yes, that was epic, especially some of Barbossa's dialouge. "Dearly beloved, we be gathered here today... to nail yer gizzard to the mast ye poxy cur

[laeria]

Oh, I've no doubt she would prepare well. Oh she'd make a fake hypersecure wedding, then elope three weeks earlier with Dawnie and Clem as witnessess. Then they'd have the fake wedding, with the Wind Beneath My Wings and Spike's various poker acquaintances and they'd have great fun until, you know, Drusilla arrived with a swirling portal to hell or something.

[thornyrose42]

Hmm... Amy Pond's wedding was quite cool. But for reasons other than the central ship.

Don't know if you'll hate me for bringing up Grey's Anatomy. But honestly its the only show I know where the marriages alternately break my heart and make me go 'ahh'. Mainly because the various weddings that have happened have been completely right for the characters. Two characters get married by writing their vows on a post it because they gave their big white wedding to the characters who actually wanted one.

I think if I tried to explain it further it would just sound even more odd but hey it is Grey's Anatomy.

As for other fictional weddings... the fact that I'm racking my brains to think of ones probably proves that none of them imprinted very much. :-)

Also you are really getting Royal Wedding Fever over in your country? Jeeze at least it is vaguely pertinent over here.

I haven't seen GoT get. Waiting for my friend to get back to uni. Don't know whether it is a bonus that I've not read the books in years.

[laeria]

Yes. I. The thing with Amy Pond's wedding is, like, in the pro column, we have ACCIO TOP HAT ELEVEN HOW DARE YOU BE LATE YOU PILLOCK and also HELLO PONDS and Eleven/River getting a twinge of chemistry for once. In the con column, we have the fact that we have no actual idea who Amy and Rory are for a lot of the wedding. Their whole storylines (and, inevitably, their love story) got uprooted, and then it all gets sorta meshed, and you really wanna know more about their new lives but you just don't

[thornyrose42]

Exactly the wedding, thematically, just really wasn't about Amy Pond and Rory. It was much more about Amy and her Raggedy Doctor and everything finally fitting together. And the moment when everything fits together is not when her and Rory get married its when Amy stands up remembers her childhood imaginary friend back into existence. Which I do love. Because its all about her believing no matter what the people around her say and bringing back the good childhood things and making the world work to her will. But its not about her and Rory

[laeria]

Yes yes, it was about friendship and about growing up not having to mean leaving wonder behind. It was brilliant in a way. (Although I am also squicked by the I-really-hope-that-was-accidental-Moffat Donna comparison, because AMY IS NOT A DONNA FIX-IT THERE IS NOTHING TO FIX GODDAMN YOU.) But, yes, not in a shippy way. I am totally with you on Amy/Rory - they confuse me. I like the THEORY of the ship, very much, love that he's okay with being her sidekick/beta, love that he's okay with defying convention for her although they matter for him. I love that she's kinky and sexually confidant and okay with letting him know it. It's great. But I don't actually - feel it in action? Like, I constantly feel we're being told, not shown, what their relationship is like. Ish. Something. But that's the crux of my Moff issues anyway, and I'm getting fairly good at watching around it

[egelantier]

john and aeryn wedding in farscape,no competition ever. they try for quite a bit to have a more, gm, traditional one, and then the one we have happens and it's just - amazing. and perfect, and them, and happens, of course, in the middle of battle, and it's something they (and you) crawled and ran and flied to over this whole time, and you want it so much, and then it's here. (hilarious and tragic and grand, at the same time).

[laeria]

ahhhhhhh. I need to watch this so much.

[egelantier]

more than anything else ever, duh. this is the only show ever that inspired me to, y'know, have enough entries in my lj for a separate tag. because it's the best. story. ever.