On AMVs

[gaudior]

So anime music videos (the downloading and watching thereof) are one of my more favorite hobbies. The really good ones do a splendid job of pointing out cool things you hadn't noticed about the series, the bad ones are at least a chance to watch the art (which is, honestly, my more favorite part of anime). And they all take you out of narrative

Comments

[occultatio]

I would simply point out that the "Ding Dong Song" Utena video does not feature a shot of Utena pulling a sword out of Anthy.

(Although, honestly, while I don't know most of the rest of these, that one isn't just a cool and powerful image, it's actively iconic and incredibly significant to the fundamental themes of the series, so I'm not sure how you could make a video about either Utena or Anthy that doesn't use it...)

[rax]

Actually, given that it is a critical moment in the work, I think a video
that spent its entire time _talking around_ that particular cut would
actually be really interesting. You could do all sorts of things with clattering
swords, Anthy holding the sword, without actually getting to that moment ---
sort of building up to it in reverse. On the other hand, maybe you might
do better with talking around the concept of the duels themselves.

I also think more should be done in AMVs with sound --- integrating the
music and sounds of the original series in an evocative way --- which
would require the creator to be both DJ and VJ.

[occultatio]

The idea of an AMV "talking around" that could actually be cool, but unless it was *really* damn good, it would need to eventually resolve the dramatic tension (I use the term in a literary sense). You can pan around Johan all you want, but sooner or later you've got to show his face. It's no fun to tease without eventually giving in.

[rax]

It's no fun to tease without eventually giving in? Bah! :)

I personally think that resolving dramatic tension is overrated. I mean,
yes, you have to resolve some of it, but I think a short piece like that
where the audience already _knows_ the answer to the question you're
asking is better when it makes you go dig out your DVDs of the series
and skip around looking for the right image to sate yourself. In general
I think it's more worthwhile to leave people with a question than an
answer; saying that having an AMV where you don't show the pivotal scene
is perhaps a bit much but I think it's headed in the right direction.

"This attitude may explain why I am not widely read"

[signy1]

There is a great song called 'Been There, Done That,' but it's awfully specific about the things the protagonist is no longer willing to do. (Fight werewolves, annoy wizards, deal with awakened mummies, etc...)

[gaudior]

Oh, for grin. (That sounds remarkably Tom Smith-ish, signy1... is it so?)

But I wonder what other song would work for that... "Time After Time" actually has too much context, and "Another One Bites the Dust" is wrong, and has been done...

But... worth thinking on.

[apintrix]

I like your list. For a while there, every single Escaflowne vid I watched ended with The Hug scene from the last episode. I got so sick of it.

Might I add: the rose falling on the puddle, from Cowboy Bebop

[gaudior]

Indeed, and absolutely. I was trying to keep it to just one shot from each series, but you're right, there are several... it would also have made sense to include the shot with Vash and the Walkman, from Trigun, or, as syonakeleste points out below, the scene with Ye Great Glowing Purple Pentagram (tm) from Yami no Matsuei.

[reversepolarity]

a) I find it funny that Muraki raping Hisoka is the first one that you came up with. :p

b) "Heero pushing the self-destruct button." THAT'S ALL HEERO DOES. If you want to make an AMV with him in it, that's all you'll get that stick-in-the-mud supersoldier to do for you. Got a mission for him? It could be buying me some fucking Reese's Puffs from the store down the street, and he'd STILL manage to have to self-detonate in order to do it. Can't even buy some cereal for his fellow pilot without blowing up half the damn town. ~.~;;

Err...was I ranting?

[gaudior]

a) Dude, my loyalty to the YnM fandom is slightly battered by an excess of obsession, but I think it may still be my One True Series. And that scene was the one which gave me the idea for the entry, so... But yes, I can see the amusement. Grin.

b) Yes, yes, you were ranting. But that's why you're our favorite pilot.

(Heh. Reese's Puffs.)

[syonakeleste]

Might I add: that scene where Muraki's in Ye Great Glowing Purple Pentagram, and the "camera" spins around him.

Ye Great Glowing Purple Pentagram also sounds like it should be a euphemism for something.

[gaudior]

Snerk. But for what?