{S2: Challenge 06} Results

[aztec]

★ Winners can request banners from custom_banners.
★ If you would like to know your voting results, comment with the number of your icon and whether you would like them screened or unscreened.
★ Submissions are now unscreened. Please get permission from the iconmaker if you want to use any of the icons from this round.

{ CHALLENGE 06 : RESULTS }
★

Comments

[envydia]

Congrats to the winners~!
Screened comments for icon #1, please?

[aztec]

03 (+6)
[ + ] The text is beautiful, and the background is, appropriately, very dramatic.
[ + ] This is just beautiful. Great coloring, good contrast fro Al to the background and nice text that matches everything but still stands out just enough to draw the eye and be readable.
[ + ] It was creative to integrate the them by using the alchemist circle. The lighting backs the icon really dramatic.
[ + ] Using an alchemic circle to fulfil the theme was brilliant.Also, the text is very pleasing to look at while still being easy to read.
[ + ] I love the contrast between fore- and background. The crop is very nicely done as well.
[ + ] Powerful icon! The lighting and crop are very dynamic, and you've used the text placement to draw everything together.

[aztec]

02 (-3)
[ - ] The opposing colors for the text split the words up, making them hard to read. The coloring for Al is also a bit odd.
[ - ] The image itself has a nice crop, however the coloring seems a little to saturated and the multi-colored text is distracting. Perhaps lightening the coloring a little and finding a single color or a different way to make the text stand out than changing the coloring halfway through a word would look better.
[ - ] The text is difficult to read and, to me, the colors just don't look right. I think the icon could have done with a little less contrast.

[implication]

Thanks for Mod's Choice and congrats to fuckyeahfish. Screened comments for #6 please.