Round One Challenge Two: Results
Challenge Two is over and we have to say goodbye to two more people. Thank you for participating and stay tuned for the comeback round!
upon_the_look did not vote and was not eligible for People's or Mod's Choice.
Eliminated:
light_ofmy_life
w/-24 votesliesl06
w/-10 votes
People’s Choice
Mod’s Choice
thenarnianqueen
w/+9 votes
you have immunity for
the next challenge :)
pokecharm
I love the use of
negative space and
the b/w is very pretty.
(People's Choice, Mod's Choice, Eliminated.)
01: (-01)(+00)
02: (-01)(+02)
03: (-00)(+01)
04: (-07)(+03)
05: (-05)(+00)
06: (-07)(+00)
07: (-24)(+00)
08: (-05)(+00)
09: (-01)(+03)
10: (-01)(+02)
11: (-02)(+01)
12: (-00)(+01)
13: (-10)(+00)
14: (-00)(+09)
15: (-00)(+01)
16: (-03)(+00)
17: (-01)(+02)
18: (-01)(+00)
19: (-05)(+00)
Reasons:
Lesser Quality
#01 - the crop is really too close, they should of backed it up more.
#02 - Half of the eye was cut off during the cropping which gives emma's face a little bit of an awkward look. However, the black and white coloring is really nice, but there is too much of a white space in the icon and the tiny text is maybe a wee bit too tiny. If a little bit of emma's head was lowered into the icon, then it would be fine.
#04 - A lot of the icon is covered by this texture/color. The cropping underneath looks okay, but much of it is obscured.
#04 - you can hardly recognize anything
#04 - the texture/white space takes up too much space in the icon, and the cropping is odd. the double image also could have been blended better.
#04 - Good coloring, but it would be better without the gray layer.
#04 - the repeated image is pointless; it should have been a lot better if it was only 1 image and maybe if we see more from emma's face on the icon;
#04 - the blending makes the icon more muddled
#04 - an interesting icon but there is so much white space that you barely focus on emma. she gets lost in the white.
#05 - Coloring is a bit dull and drab in that it doesn't compliment or highlight Emma's feature. The black text also looks out of place because it doesn't match the color scheme of the rest of the image.
#05 - the image looks a little blurry and the font doesn't fit with the icon
#05 - the text somehow ruin the icon and the icon is just like the original photo
#05 - the colouring is dull and doesn't make the icon stand out much
#05 - The text looks awkward.
#06 - Bad cropping.
#06 - the idea with the frame and the b/w is pretty good but the crop isn't the best choice
#06 - the border makes the icon look too dark
#06 - the border spoils the icon abit
#06 - the dark frame is too big and seems out of place here
#06 - the crop is weird, her nose is cut off
#06 - the cropping is awkward with half emma's nose being chopped off.
#07 - the aspect ratio wasn't maintained when cropped.
#07 - the icon is oversharpened
#07 - the colouring is a bit dull and the image is distorted and stretched (esp. the face);
#07 - The picture looks weird. Somehow it got distorted. Too much sharpen.
#07 - the aspect ratio is off. she is too squished together.
#07 - the image is all stretched out wrong and it's oversharpened
#07 - the picture is way to sharp, it should be softer
#07 - The aspect ratio is off vertically making Emma look wider than she actually is. The edges of color (especially around her lips, eyes, hair, and fingers) are also very pixelated/oversharpened.
#07 - Emma looks stretched, it's oversharpened. There's this colored border around Emma and it's really weird and distracting, not flattering at all.
#07 - it's really pixelized
#07 - too sharp and overstretched
#07 - emma looks really stretched out and distorted, and her face especially is pixely
#07 - There is a great use of texture in the icon, but the image is stretched and squished.
#07 - the icon is abit stretched
#07 - aspect ratio is off and the image is too sharp
#07 - The icon is oversharpened and the image gets to large.
#07 - the icon is overly sharpened and pixelated
#07 - the aspect ratio is off & the image is oversharpened.
#07 - the scale of the picture has been altered, making her face look squashed.
#07 - Very oversharpened and the image is stretched horizontally.
#07 - the picture is oversharpen and blurred.
#07 - the icon is really over sharpened and awkward looking.
#07 - oversharpened and the icon looks very stretched
#07 - Violated proportions of image
#08 - Not enough sharpness
#08 - the coloring is a little bit to dark and the icon looks a little bit unsharpen.
#08 - the crop is too simple
#08 - this barely a coloring, and it's way too soft
#08 - the cropping is too centered and unoriginal.
#09 - there's not enough contrast and shadowing left...the image looks very flat and lifeless.
#10 - Oversharpened in her hair and face.
#11 - The text seems out of place, and the cropping didn't work well.
#11 - beautiful crop but the text on the side is distracting due to the font which looks sharp instead of blending in with the image.
#13 - The icon is very pixilated and the texture is overpowering. Emma's face is too bright, lacks detail.
#13 - the texture overpowers the icon and washes out her face
#13 - the lighting/texture overpowers the image
#13 - the texture is to strong around emma's face. it makes her face look washed out.
#13 - the textures are overwhelming, making it difficult to tell who the subject is.
#13 - the lighting/texture used causes emma's face to be too bright and her face loses definition.
#13 - looks unclear in the middle and too bleak closer to the middle
#13 - the crop is great but the used texture makes especially her face too bright
#13 - the colouring is abit overpowering
#13 - The texture washes emma's face out. The yellow background is a bit distracting.
#16 - the crop isn't very good because there's too much white space
#16 - the colouring is unflattering on her skin and the image is too sharp
#16 - the icon is oversharpened and her face looks too orange
#17 - There are too many textures, and they take over the icon. The textures don't interact with Emma, they distract from her.
#18 - There's not enough contrast, the texture doesn't work well with the icon.
#19 - Orange coloring looks too bright
#19 - the coloring is to dark and yellowish.
#19 - the coloring is too orange.
#19 - it looks like there's too much saturation, and the coloring is too orange.
#19 - there is too much yellow in the icon;
Favorite
#02 - The cropping is adorable, the use of off space too. It is the most different use of the image in this challenge and it looks great! :D
#02 - the negative space draws your attention to the image & the crop is lovely.
#03 - the coloring and the icon overall is really soft, which fits the picture
#04 - creative and effective blend
#04 - originally, I was going to vote this one off, but the more I studied it, the more I loved it. The cropping and placement is really original and very unique. The coloring is beautiful. Great job.
#04 - This icon is very creative, and the effect is lovely
#09 - good crop, there's no excess things, amazing b/w colors, great use of text
#09 - Nice crop, color and text use
#09 - the b/w use is beautiful and I like the light effect
#10 - The icon is sharp and the coloring is amazing!
#10 - Awesome coloring and cropping!
#11 - original icon, the crop is nice and the text fit the icon well
#12 - nice, soft colouring
#14 - Good cropping and coloring.
#14 - great colouring and cropping
#14 - great crop and nice colouring
#14 - gorgeous close crop, and the pink-ish coloring looks great
#14 - beautiful crop!
#14 - great crop and color
#14 - lovely close crop with perfect colouring
#14 - Perfect close crop and natural coloring
#14 - There was a nice change of coloring to the image, which made it look pinkish. The cropping is great and the quality in general is good.
#15 - nice crop and really pretty soft colours;
#17 - Beautiful coloring. Great use of texture.
#17 - everything flows really nicely.
Challenge Three will be posted soon!
upon_the_look did not vote and was not eligible for People's or Mod's Choice.
Eliminated:
light_ofmy_life
w/-24 votesliesl06
w/-10 votes
People’s Choice
Mod’s Choice
thenarnianqueen
w/+9 votes
you have immunity for
the next challenge :)
pokecharm
I love the use of
negative space and
the b/w is very pretty.
(People's Choice, Mod's Choice, Eliminated.)
01: (-01)(+00)
02: (-01)(+02)
03: (-00)(+01)
04: (-07)(+03)
05: (-05)(+00)
06: (-07)(+00)
07: (-24)(+00)
08: (-05)(+00)
09: (-01)(+03)
10: (-01)(+02)
11: (-02)(+01)
12: (-00)(+01)
13: (-10)(+00)
14: (-00)(+09)
15: (-00)(+01)
16: (-03)(+00)
17: (-01)(+02)
18: (-01)(+00)
19: (-05)(+00)
Reasons:
Lesser Quality
#01 - the crop is really too close, they should of backed it up more.
#02 - Half of the eye was cut off during the cropping which gives emma's face a little bit of an awkward look. However, the black and white coloring is really nice, but there is too much of a white space in the icon and the tiny text is maybe a wee bit too tiny. If a little bit of emma's head was lowered into the icon, then it would be fine.
#04 - A lot of the icon is covered by this texture/color. The cropping underneath looks okay, but much of it is obscured.
#04 - you can hardly recognize anything
#04 - the texture/white space takes up too much space in the icon, and the cropping is odd. the double image also could have been blended better.
#04 - Good coloring, but it would be better without the gray layer.
#04 - the repeated image is pointless; it should have been a lot better if it was only 1 image and maybe if we see more from emma's face on the icon;
#04 - the blending makes the icon more muddled
#04 - an interesting icon but there is so much white space that you barely focus on emma. she gets lost in the white.
#05 - Coloring is a bit dull and drab in that it doesn't compliment or highlight Emma's feature. The black text also looks out of place because it doesn't match the color scheme of the rest of the image.
#05 - the image looks a little blurry and the font doesn't fit with the icon
#05 - the text somehow ruin the icon and the icon is just like the original photo
#05 - the colouring is dull and doesn't make the icon stand out much
#05 - The text looks awkward.
#06 - Bad cropping.
#06 - the idea with the frame and the b/w is pretty good but the crop isn't the best choice
#06 - the border makes the icon look too dark
#06 - the border spoils the icon abit
#06 - the dark frame is too big and seems out of place here
#06 - the crop is weird, her nose is cut off
#06 - the cropping is awkward with half emma's nose being chopped off.
#07 - the aspect ratio wasn't maintained when cropped.
#07 - the icon is oversharpened
#07 - the colouring is a bit dull and the image is distorted and stretched (esp. the face);
#07 - The picture looks weird. Somehow it got distorted. Too much sharpen.
#07 - the aspect ratio is off. she is too squished together.
#07 - the image is all stretched out wrong and it's oversharpened
#07 - the picture is way to sharp, it should be softer
#07 - The aspect ratio is off vertically making Emma look wider than she actually is. The edges of color (especially around her lips, eyes, hair, and fingers) are also very pixelated/oversharpened.
#07 - Emma looks stretched, it's oversharpened. There's this colored border around Emma and it's really weird and distracting, not flattering at all.
#07 - it's really pixelized
#07 - too sharp and overstretched
#07 - emma looks really stretched out and distorted, and her face especially is pixely
#07 - There is a great use of texture in the icon, but the image is stretched and squished.
#07 - the icon is abit stretched
#07 - aspect ratio is off and the image is too sharp
#07 - The icon is oversharpened and the image gets to large.
#07 - the icon is overly sharpened and pixelated
#07 - the aspect ratio is off & the image is oversharpened.
#07 - the scale of the picture has been altered, making her face look squashed.
#07 - Very oversharpened and the image is stretched horizontally.
#07 - the picture is oversharpen and blurred.
#07 - the icon is really over sharpened and awkward looking.
#07 - oversharpened and the icon looks very stretched
#07 - Violated proportions of image
#08 - Not enough sharpness
#08 - the coloring is a little bit to dark and the icon looks a little bit unsharpen.
#08 - the crop is too simple
#08 - this barely a coloring, and it's way too soft
#08 - the cropping is too centered and unoriginal.
#09 - there's not enough contrast and shadowing left...the image looks very flat and lifeless.
#10 - Oversharpened in her hair and face.
#11 - The text seems out of place, and the cropping didn't work well.
#11 - beautiful crop but the text on the side is distracting due to the font which looks sharp instead of blending in with the image.
#13 - The icon is very pixilated and the texture is overpowering. Emma's face is too bright, lacks detail.
#13 - the texture overpowers the icon and washes out her face
#13 - the lighting/texture overpowers the image
#13 - the texture is to strong around emma's face. it makes her face look washed out.
#13 - the textures are overwhelming, making it difficult to tell who the subject is.
#13 - the lighting/texture used causes emma's face to be too bright and her face loses definition.
#13 - looks unclear in the middle and too bleak closer to the middle
#13 - the crop is great but the used texture makes especially her face too bright
#13 - the colouring is abit overpowering
#13 - The texture washes emma's face out. The yellow background is a bit distracting.
#16 - the crop isn't very good because there's too much white space
#16 - the colouring is unflattering on her skin and the image is too sharp
#16 - the icon is oversharpened and her face looks too orange
#17 - There are too many textures, and they take over the icon. The textures don't interact with Emma, they distract from her.
#18 - There's not enough contrast, the texture doesn't work well with the icon.
#19 - Orange coloring looks too bright
#19 - the coloring is to dark and yellowish.
#19 - the coloring is too orange.
#19 - it looks like there's too much saturation, and the coloring is too orange.
#19 - there is too much yellow in the icon;
Favorite
#02 - The cropping is adorable, the use of off space too. It is the most different use of the image in this challenge and it looks great! :D
#02 - the negative space draws your attention to the image & the crop is lovely.
#03 - the coloring and the icon overall is really soft, which fits the picture
#04 - creative and effective blend
#04 - originally, I was going to vote this one off, but the more I studied it, the more I loved it. The cropping and placement is really original and very unique. The coloring is beautiful. Great job.
#04 - This icon is very creative, and the effect is lovely
#09 - good crop, there's no excess things, amazing b/w colors, great use of text
#09 - Nice crop, color and text use
#09 - the b/w use is beautiful and I like the light effect
#10 - The icon is sharp and the coloring is amazing!
#10 - Awesome coloring and cropping!
#11 - original icon, the crop is nice and the text fit the icon well
#12 - nice, soft colouring
#14 - Good cropping and coloring.
#14 - great colouring and cropping
#14 - great crop and nice colouring
#14 - gorgeous close crop, and the pink-ish coloring looks great
#14 - beautiful crop!
#14 - great crop and color
#14 - lovely close crop with perfect colouring
#14 - Perfect close crop and natural coloring
#14 - There was a nice change of coloring to the image, which made it look pinkish. The cropping is great and the quality in general is good.
#15 - nice crop and really pretty soft colours;
#17 - Beautiful coloring. Great use of texture.
#17 - everything flows really nicely.
Challenge Three will be posted soon!