Reactions: The Girl in the Fireplace

Jan 31, 2008 03:17


Featuring this episode's special guest commentators...


Read more... )

2x04 the girl in the fireplace

Leave a comment

Comments 69

ivydoor January 31 2008, 13:25:28 UTC
BWAHAHAHAHAHAHA!

I HEART YOU SO MUCH FOR THIS! OMG Funniest rewatch review EVER.

Reply

principia January 31 2008, 20:03:42 UTC
Does this mean we won't be treated to one of your marvelous drunken recaps? :(

Reply

ivydoor January 31 2008, 20:16:48 UTC
HA! I think we'll get one done by this weekend. *makes mental note to poke dettiot* I have no idea how we'll beat this. I really think this is the best review idea I have ever seen. Absolutely brilliant.

Three snaps in Z-formation! *snap* *snap* *snap*

Reply

principia January 31 2008, 20:22:57 UTC
I have no idea how we'll beat this. I really think this is the best review idea I have ever seen. Absolutely brilliant.

*blushes*

I wasn't trying to steal your thunder, honestly... but after I made a snarky comment in obsessive_caps, larissa_j dared me! Of course, she didn't have to make it a double-dog dare for me to go along, but still...

The fellows will probably only reoccur for the episodes for which I find the adage 'If you can't say anything nice, come and sit next to me!' applies. If there are any specific episodes you'd like to see this for prior to Series 3, let me know...

Reply


jai_23 January 31 2008, 13:26:19 UTC
Oh. My. God. [dies] :P

I don't even know who these two are and yet this is the funniest thing ever!

Ha, I'll never be able to look at this episode in the same way ever again! (Not that I ever watch it anyway, it hurts. And has no continuity.)

Thank you so much! :)

Reply

ivydoor January 31 2008, 15:12:25 UTC
I don't even know who these two are and yet this is the funniest thing ever!

Get thee to YOUTUBE! I miss that show so much.

Reply

jai_23 January 31 2008, 16:43:39 UTC
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA, how can I not have seen this before? Totally made of fabulous win! Ohhhhhh, they're so amazing! My mouth hurts from laughing so much! :)

"When we talk about Mel Gibson's 'Lethal Weapon'."

"I hope it's loaded."

Thank you sooooooooooooooo much!

Reply

ivydoor January 31 2008, 16:53:40 UTC
Oh, and don't forget Men on Cooking! "Bite sized, too!" Hee! And if you want to see something really frightening, do a search for Vera De Milo. *giggles*

Reply


marble_rose January 31 2008, 13:39:45 UTC
I'd worked myself up into a nice seethe over this episode, but then you created this and it made all the badness go away. Really, this has to be the best experience I've had in relation to this episode. Thank you.

Reply

principia January 31 2008, 20:05:22 UTC
*bows*

It was either these guys or Tom Servo & Co., so I'm glad this hit the spot for you!

Reply


leighleighla January 31 2008, 14:38:25 UTC
*spits out juice*

Aw...aw...gotta go change my shirt now...damn. That was amazing.

And now I want to write GitFace + Jack. Thanks.

Reply

principia January 31 2008, 20:06:02 UTC
...and Jack wakes up in bed with MdP, King Louis and one of the clockwork droids...

Reply

leighleighla January 31 2008, 20:07:31 UTC
Jack: Damn! How much did I drink last night?!?!

Reply

principia January 31 2008, 20:11:36 UTC
Jack is such a girl drink drunk!

Reply


larissa_j January 31 2008, 14:53:22 UTC
Oh snap, this is brilliant! You took the idea and really ran with it! I'm going to be laughing all the way into work. Is it wrong that I want SM to see this?

How about The Temptress in the Tandoor?

*snort* I was waiting for "can we throw her back in, like a fish?"

Captain Naked As Often As Possible had been there, he woulda swept Madame de PomPom off her feet...

That might have saved the episode. At least Jack would have knocked some sense into the Doctor, literally.

You know what LotTL needs? That's right, A Men on Film version!

Reply

principia January 31 2008, 15:42:08 UTC
Is it wrong that I want SM to see this?

No. I think this should be printed out by the people at the production offices and taped to the wall, so they remember when the time comes for the departure of the current PTB.

*snort* I was waiting for "can we throw her back in, like a fish?"

Throw her back in to what? (A Tandoor is a traditional style of charcoal oven used in places like India and the Mideast; maybe I shouldn't have assumed everyone would know what that was)

You know what LotTL needs? That's right, A Men on Film version!

That is actually the plan. If I can find a LJ client that lets me post pictures I can see as I'm working and behaves similarly to the Rich Text editor without all the kludginess, that'll make doing these much faster (see my query to dettiot above).

Reply

larissa_j January 31 2008, 17:23:01 UTC
*snort* I was waiting for "can we throw her back in, like a fish?"

Okay, lj is being weird. I deleted this comment on my way out the door because I thought it was wanky. Why is it is still here? I guess my youtube embedded clip got deleted? I must have deleted the wrong one? OY. Early morning issues.

Okay then. Still here. That was supposed to be Blaine and Antoine. *sigh* Anyway...

If I can find a LJ client that lets me post pictures I can see as I'm working and behaves similarly to the Rich Text editor without all the kludginess,

Have you tried semagic?

Reply

principia January 31 2008, 17:32:12 UTC
Why is it is still here? I guess my youtube embedded clip got deleted? I must have deleted the wrong one? OY. Early morning issues.

There is indeed no media in that comment. I thought maybe you just didn't know what a tandoor was.

Besides, if people were going to get in a dander I'd think my post provided well more than enough targets to distract people from your comment. XD

Of course, now that I've gone back and done links half of them are blue, but I'm sick of trying percussive maintenance on the rich text editor.

Have you tried semagic?

I have Semagic at home because I'd gotten it over the summer for crossposting to multiple journals when it looked like LJ might implode, but unless there are plug-ins I'm missing it's actually pretty basic.

My friend killernurd suggested trying Deepest Sender, which is a Firefox plug-in. I don't have FF here at work, but it's certainly something I'll try later.

ETA: And editing again...

Do you think this should be behind a Teen filter?

Reply


Leave a comment

Up