ROUND THREE: CHALLENGE ONE: RESULTS

Sep 23, 2009 21:57

Sorry for the delay, we had a tie for both elimination AND people's choice this week. (Also, my arms are dead from my swim class DX).

results )

round three, r3:c01, results

Leave a comment

Comments 6

senbonzakura77 September 24 2009, 03:33:10 UTC
Congratulations to both winners! :)

May I please have the comments for icon #2? (unscreened is fine)

Reply

carnimirie September 26 2009, 03:37:59 UTC
+ 02 - I think the composition is very nice, simple and clean. It's easy on the eyes as well.
+ 02 - This one stood out because of it's uniqueness. The cropping of the image maximized the use of texture/s to create a lovely effect. The bright coloring also fits the 'mood' of the whole icon.
- #2 - The filmstrip texture and the image don't seem to really match. Perhaps a little text might tie them together better.

Reply


kyoy September 24 2009, 08:12:07 UTC
Congrats! I really like that celestial icon~

Too bad I missed voting ;o;

Comments for #4 please? Unscreened is alright, thanks~

Reply

carnimirie September 26 2009, 03:39:17 UTC
- 04 - I think the cropping could have been better, and the color is a little too blue. The text is a little hard to read as well.
+ #4 - The text placement is wonderful - the small size also helps to highlight Kaguya.
+ #4 - Good job using color to tie all the elements together and unifying the composition.
+ 04 - The blue tint to this really works with the image, and the text is quite readable without becoming a major focus of the icon. Very interesting.
- 04 - I just didn't care for the coloring. Too much blue.

Reply


coloredpastels September 25 2009, 05:20:34 UTC
#3 screened comments please.

Reply


whitelilies22 September 26 2009, 03:27:44 UTC
Lols, totally saw that one coming XD Screened comments please?

Reply


Leave a comment

Up