Soy

Dec 06, 2005 15:54

There has been much news recently about reports that soy is actually bad for you. Most of those reports stem for problems with soy's protein digestibility, which apparently are rendered moot in tofu, tempeh, soy milk, and other slightly processed products, and from studies done on animals, which fed the animals incredibly large amounts of soy from birth and focused on creatures such as rats, who have very different nutritional requirements from humans.  Rats would also not do well on human breast milk (with 5% protein vs. 45% protein in rat milk). This is the equivalent of concluding that chocolate is a deadly poison for humans by testing its affects on cats. The anti-soy articles also talked about how Asians really don't eat much soy, as if all of Asia were one monolithic entity with 2.5 billion people. Breaking it down into smaller groups, the people with the highest lifespans on the planet, the Okinawans, eat quite a lot of soy (12% of their diets for the elders), and studies done on them reason that their soy intake is a big reason for their good health.

Here's a well reasoned retort to the soy naysaysers from John Robbins, who wrote Diet for a New America and The Food Revolution (and who has no relationship with the soy industry).

Ultimately, eat things in moderation.  Too many meat-eaters switch to getting all their protein from soy when they become vegetarian or vegan.  Anything in excess is bad from you, whether it's spinach, blueberries, or soy (all "Superfoods").  Get your protein from lentils, beans, dairy (if lacto), eggs (if ovo), and other sources as well as soy.

And if you are a meat eater who is going to switch to being vegetarian, do so slowly, as one of my friends did back in college.  Every few months he would make another day of the week be meat-free.  This allows both your body and mind time to adapt.
Previous post Next post
Up