Comments | zatnikatel: The Killing Moon

zatnikatel

The Killing Moon

Dec 14, 2009 09:54

It's over! Finally! I wanted to thank you lovely people for commenting: I really appreciate your feedback and it so inspired me. You all rock! And wow: over 1,000 reviews on FF, here and elsewhere. I'm overwhelmed ( Read more... )

the killing moon, spn fic

Comments 17

cadia58 December 14 2009, 15:12:05 UTC

Heya, Kate!!!!
I already went over to FF.net (am I stalking you???) to read it there......it definitely works, but for me D & K all the way, think, you guessed that, huh?!

XOXOXO

zatnikatel December 14 2009, 15:24:55 UTC

You know I guess I sorta am D/K too, though I never intended going there initially. Thought they deserved their moment but I do really like the other one too with the fact she never knows he came by [gulps]. Hey, leave me a review at FF if you get a minute, sugah! Keep those numbers going up for me. I accept anonymous reviews there so you don't have to register - just sign your name so I know it's you! ;-)

cadia58 December 14 2009, 15:38:52 UTC

Okay, the duty of a minion.....BUT I simply copy my review from here to there, okay?? I´m exhausted (awwww) and to push numbers that would be enough AND you don´t have to reply to it - I´m soooo clever, right??!!!!!!

zatnikatel December 14 2009, 15:43:05 UTC

Shure thing hon! I'm riding you hard and putting you away wet today, fer shure! ;-)

Thread 6

dawnintheforest December 14 2009, 18:16:32 UTC

I'm definitely all about the D/K. Although I would've gone for B/K too. No triangle, *shudders*, but you know instead. Maybe Bobby's too old for Kathleen? How old is she? I think I've asked this before, but I've managed to forget. I've never gotten a handle on how old she is. 30s? 40s?

Congrats on finishing this fic. I've really enjoyed the ride, the whole ride. We've (you, readers/minions, and the characters) come so far since the beginnings of The Woods are Lonely, Dark, and Deep.
I'm not surprised that you've received so many reviews. Your writing is gripping and of such high quality, after all.

(Ok, now time to respond to our other conversation/comment-thread.)

zatnikatel December 15 2009, 19:39:37 UTC

You know, a lot of people over on FF shipped Kathleen and Bobby initially! But yes, Bobby sex... not sure about that one. Someone told me there is Bobby/Dean slash, which just makes me want to reach for the bleach.

sandymg December 14 2009, 23:06:13 UTC

Can never comment to many times on this fantastic story. I like this ending. Feels very organic. Read the other one. A little too bleak for me. Maybe if the story overall had been lighter. But, hon, light it's not! Also the scene with D/K was so powerful when they first got together. He so needed her just then. This made the revisit so poignant. It see it as part of his overall healing ... I think while it seems like a little change to the ending ... in reality it could resonate emotionally for Dean for a long time. So, this is the only ending in my mind. So there! :)

Thanks so much for this tale.

It was such a long, fulfilling pleasure.

zatnikatel December 15 2009, 19:37:54 UTC

I still don't know which one I like better! Oh, OK, maybe the first one by just a smidgin.

Really because I think the fact he prowls up to her and leans in all intimidating [go on, close your eyes and just imagine it...] and then kisses her neck is so *chaste* that it's scorching hot...

There is something to be said for leaving it to the imagination now and then! Although i my case it's because I would die of embarrassment if I ever had to write a 'proper' sex scene. :-O

It's the Roman Catholic in me, I think, though I lapsed years ago... ;-)

sandymg December 15 2009, 23:31:25 UTC

Umm ... I hope you aren't coming down with amnesia. You did have a "proper" sex scene in the story earlier. That's what started the whole ship thing! I liked that scene. Wuz hot.

zatnikatel December 16 2009, 00:08:14 UTC

Well yeah… but that was still hot because of all the gory details it left out! :-D

Thread 7

anmita December 15 2009, 19:18:57 UTC

...is it....is it wrong that I cried?

zatnikatel December 15 2009, 19:32:03 UTC

No! In fact it is incredibly sweet that you did! I'm not entirely sure which ending I prefer actually... maybe the other one but only by a hair because I like that they have their moment of peace in it - but I also like this one because he follows through on what he said about leaving her to get on with her life, even to the extent of saying that he's Sam so she'll never know he stopped by. It makes me all watery-eyed too because he's so *noble*!