Noms review post 2
This post is now closed. Please refer to the most recent Noms Review Post.
We’re still sorting through the remaining nominations - the current count is 3676 down, 1196 more to go.
Thanks to everyone who has helped with clarifications so far.
The outstanding questions for the moment (fandoms in bold):
Reminder: if you see fandoms or characters rejected that you thought were eligible, it may be that they have been accepted under a different name. Please wait until the tagset is public to query any problems of this sort.
Comments on this post will be open until around this time tomorrow. It will then be frozen and the next post opened with any remaining (and new) questions.
This has been crossposted to Dreamwidth.
We’re still sorting through the remaining nominations - the current count is 3676 down, 1196 more to go.
Thanks to everyone who has helped with clarifications so far.
The outstanding questions for the moment (fandoms in bold):
- Pop Music RPF - from the list of characters (Ariana Grande, Nicki Minaj, Jessie J, Backup Dancers), it looks like Bang Bang (Music Video) RPF might be more accurate?
- The School for Good and Evil - Soman Chainani - tags in question are Sophie (The School for Good and Evil) and Filip. From a summary of the book, it seems that Sophie goes undercover in the boys' dorm magically disguised as "Filip". Sophie and Filip have been nominated separately. Are these actually separate characters?
- Prince of Silk and Thorns - Cherry Dare - there are 4 characters nominated: Alar, Alazne, Garrin (correct spelling: Garin) and a 4th that we can’t find. Can someone confirm that Lierni is a canonical character and/or the correct spelling?
- Drujienna's Harp - Ellen Kindt McKenzie - we can’t identify the character Elnorade.
- Something Bad (Miranda Lambert song), characters: Carrie Underwood, Miranda Lambert. The fandom tag is for the song, but the characters are for RPF - which one did you want?
- Don’t Rest Your Face - the fandom was nominated without a disambiguation or characters, did you mean the tabletop game?
- The Book of Manson - Raymond Pettibon - the format for this nomination implies that it is a published book. However, we can only find it as a movie - which media category should it go in?
- Vienna Teng (Musician) - did you mean to nominate a Vienna Teng album? The characters nominated under this fandom are all from her songs, and the (Musician) disambig is for RPF fandoms.
- The fandom Hellcats has been accidentally rejected. If you have nominated this fandom, please leave a comment with your nominated characters, as we only have a partial list of nominated characters saved for it.
- Road Not Taken (Video Game) - the characters you nominated have an impressive array of piped variations. Ie, Funeral Singer (Fedor | Ralph | Marvin | Scott | Dave) - can you help us understand why all of those names are there?
- The Littl' Bits - should this be categorized as "Anime & Manga" or "Cartoons & Comics & Graphic Novels"?
Reminder: if you see fandoms or characters rejected that you thought were eligible, it may be that they have been accepted under a different name. Please wait until the tagset is public to query any problems of this sort.
Comments on this post will be open until around this time tomorrow. It will then be frozen and the next post opened with any remaining (and new) questions.
This has been crossposted to Dreamwidth.