The tag set has been reopened for vetting. As it was unclear which problems should go in the form, the form will remain closed and all problems should be noted in the comments of this post
( Read more... )
Ultimates != the Ultimate Universe, so that name is nonsensical. The argument that most of these characters aren't Ult Spider-Man characters is also hard to believe when, as mentioned above about 2/3 of the characters are unarguably Ult Spider-Man characters, and many of the characters left also have a big presence in Ult Spider-Man (Johnny, especially) and therefore can conceivably be nominated under that tag as well. Maybe you are unaware that Spider-Man Ultverse applies to both the Ultimate Spider-Man comic (featuring Peter Parker) and the Ultimate Comics: Spider-Man title (featuring Miles Morales), both that basically function as Vol 1 and Vol 2 of a series, since both include several of the same characters, and that's why you thought nominations were wrong?
I mean, I get that Yuletide is a lot of work, seriously, I get it. But if you would just trust the fans to know where things go and accept them the way they are, you wouldn't have to do all this extra work. If Pietro or Wanda had ended up in the Ult SM tag, the fans would have let you know they didn't belong there. But policing the nominations and then not acknowledging you've made a mistake when numerous fans have already told you multiple times in multiple posts that you have is seriously unfair.
Ultimates != the Ultimate Universe, so that name is nonsensical. The argument that most of these characters aren't Ult Spider-Man characters is also hard to believe when, as mentioned above about 2/3 of the characters are unarguably Ult Spider-Man characters, and many of the characters left also have a big presence in Ult Spider-Man (Johnny, especially) and therefore can conceivably be nominated under that tag as well. Maybe you are unaware that Spider-Man Ultverse applies to both the Ultimate Spider-Man comic (featuring Peter Parker) and the Ultimate Comics: Spider-Man title (featuring Miles Morales), both that basically function as Vol 1 and Vol 2 of a series, since both include several of the same characters, and that's why you thought nominations were wrong?
I mean, I get that Yuletide is a lot of work, seriously, I get it. But if you would just trust the fans to know where things go and accept them the way they are, you wouldn't have to do all this extra work. If Pietro or Wanda had ended up in the Ult SM tag, the fans would have let you know they didn't belong there. But policing the nominations and then not acknowledging you've made a mistake when numerous fans have already told you multiple times in multiple posts that you have is seriously unfair.
Reply
Leave a comment