I have a strange, strange love for AUs.
In particular, serial killer!AUs. I think exploring the boys' relationship when they aren't the good guys is just thought-provoking, and maybe...maybe I have a thing for sociopath!Dean. Maybe.
Anyway, I have (with great difficulty, through blood and tears) compiled a rec list for serial killer AUs. Be sure to read all the warnings--these are some pretty hardcore fics, with some very graphic content.
With that said, I hope you all enjoy these stories as much as I did. :)
Sam/Dean, Gen
The Lady Killers by
thrdstrike (Sam/Dean)--> Request for a PDF
here Darker Shade of Black by
sardonicsmiley (Sam/Dean, 14A) They say that no one can get out of here. Never been done. Never will be done. Sam's heard that before, and Dean has never, ever, been wrong about his prediction on how long it will take them to get out. He's good that way.
Hedonistic by
cha (Sam/Dean, NC-17) Hedonistic: noun: a person whose life is devoted to the pursuit of pleasure and self-gratification. Dean likes to kill, Sam likes to obsess. When they come together it's more than either could anticipate.
Dark and Deadly by
blueeyedliz (Sam/Dean, NC-17) Sam and Dean have an incest kink.
The 'Strangers' series by
hopefulwriter27 (Sam/Dean, R) Sam and Dean are evil. They like to kill.
We Are Legion by
aelfsiden(Sam/Dean, NC-17) To release Dean from his bargain Sam gives up both their souls.
The 'Howl' series by
paxlux (Sam/Dean, NC-17) In Hell, people change. Or they stay the same.
Bad Moon Rising (Portland OR) by
red_handed (Sam/Dean, R) Dean is a profiler's worst nightmare.
Carve by
tebtosca (Dean Smith, Gen-R) "My pain is constant and sharp, and I do not hope for a better world for anyone. In fact, I want my pain to be inflicted on others. I want no one to escape." (American Psycho, 2000)
Mercury, Salt, and Sulfur by
pyrebi (Sam, Dean, PG-13) An AU tag to 3.15 Time Is On My Side
This is Not an Exit by
portraitofafool (Sam/Dean, NC-17) Off-screen season six AU.
Natural Born Hunters by
hugemind (Sam/Dean, NC-17) Based off of the film "Natural Born Killers"
Supernatural Born Killers by
sugarbucket (Sam/Dean, NC-17) Based off of the film "Natural Born Killers"
Out Here in the Fields by
honeylocusttree (Sam/Dean, PG-13) Hendrickson interviews Sam in a world where monsters don't exist.
Sons of Atreus by
tigriswolf (Implied Sam/Dean, R) Sam was six when he fell in love with death.
J2 AUs
We'll Dance All Night ('til the House Falls Down) by
fleshflutter(J2) This is the tale of deaf!serial-killer!attendant!Jensen and insane!underage!Jared in a mental hospital, as conceived by lazy_daze and balefully.
Colors by
englishblue(J2) Serial killers beware. Jared is the go to guy for revenge.
A Touch of Evil by
thenyxie (J2, NC-17) Jensen is an accomplished forensic pathologist hiding a secret life as a serial killer, and Jared is the best trauma surgeon in the Dallas area. Somewhere in the middle, they meet.