Discussion Post

[yj_anon]

Discussion!

You post it here!

Same kind of be-polite-etc. rules apply as in the main post! Just in case anyone wants to discuss anything and doesn't want to clutter up the meme.

Comments

Re: Robin in Slytherin?

[dr_harbinger]

I honestly would place Robin in Ravenclaw. He's a smart kid, smarter than most, and while he certainly has factors of bravery and loyalty that could put him in Gryffindor and Hufflepuff, I think he's too cerebral, too focused on knowledge to belong to houses that focus on other traits. Slytherin wouldn't fit him either because he's not a particularly ambitious boy. He seems more than content enough with being Batman's sidekick and doesn't mind being called such a thing so he's definitely not a Slytherin.

So my selections would be

Robin - Ravenclaw
KF - Gryffindor ( he stands up to people when he needs to and doesn't mind jumping head first into things that are very very dangerous )
M'gann - Hufflepuff
Kaldur - Ravenclaw ( he's too calm and strategic to be a Gryffindor )
Superboy - Hufflepuff ( he's loyal to a fault and vicious like a disgruntled badger! His bravery, I think, comes from the fact that he's practically invincible.)
Artemis - Slytherin ( wouldn't put it passed her to give up her teammates for something that's beneficial to her )
Speedy - Slytherin ( He's ambitious and willing to do almost anything to get the job done )

Re: Robin in Slytherin?

[hearttooread]

You know, I actually really like your selection. Dammit! lol Way to influence my earlier thoughts on this. But really though, I get it, and its split pretty evenly among the houses (except for Wally lol But he gets placed with out fav Hogwarts trio!) and it just really fits with a lot of their more prominent traits.
Hope this gets written soon!... (Oh by the way, I'm the Anon you we're replying too :D)

Oh, and on another note... have you read the Fill on Hogwarts with Bruce as the Potions Master? lol Its good!! But I wouldn't mind another one.... ^_^