1. Bo Bice, "Remedy" - Simon's right, the song sucked, but Bo's still a good performer. However, he gets no vote from me tonight because of his stupid cow pun.
2. Jessica Sierra, some Leann Rimes song I've never heard of - Booooring. And she didn't really do that modulation very well.
3. Anwar Robinson, "I Believe I Can Fly" - Simon and Randy were right. Anwar concentrating on the bug finish rather than what's leadnig up to it. I think his classical training is really hurting him. Listen to how he sang the word "fly" at the end - he opened up the vowel to sing the note cleaner, which is a classical cheat for high notes. Except that he changed the sound too much, and that's not good when everyone knows this freaking song backwards and forwards.
4. Nadia Turner, "I'm the Only One" - Randy's full of shit. Nadia's one of the best voices in the competition. I have never heard her sing out of tune once, unlike everyone else. The only thing that seems to be up with her singing is that she seems to be running out of air at the ends of her phrases. But that was a great performance tonight. I'm voting for her twice.
5. Constantine Maroulis, "I Can't Make You Love Me" - Meh. I wanted him to do a rock song tonight. The vocals were pretty good, I'll agree with the judges on that. And is that his dad they keep cutting away to? That man creeps me out.
Oh, that's Simon runs out during the commericals. He's going for a smoke break. Next time, Simon, don't leave the lighter in your hand, it's a little obvious.
6. Nikko Smith, I have no idea what his song is - UGLY jacket. Good performance.
7. Anthony Federov, "Something about the Way You Look Tonight" - He needs to put his glasses back on. And his performace was saved by the really good ending. Otherwise, meh.
8. Carrie Underwood, "Independence Day" - She always starts her songs out of tunes, looks like she's about to cry, and never smiles while she's singing. She's practically as dull as white toast, so why do the judges adore her?!?!?!?!
9. Scott Savol, "One Last Cry" - That sucked. Yep. Sucked muchly.
10. Vonzell Solomon, "I Have Nothing" - Wow, Paula actually noticed that she went higher than Whitney. But Vonzell took on a Whitney Houston song and survived, so I'm voting for her too.