From Elf... already posted it in a reply to her but oh well...
You Are A: Lamb!
Peaceful and gentle, lambs have been used in religious imagery for millennia. Lambs are baby sheep, an animal tended by shephards since the dawn of history. As a lamb, you tend to stay together in a flock and graze on grassy land. Lambs don't mind being led and tend not to go off on their own.
You were almost a: Kitten or a Pony
You are least like a: Mouse or a ParakeetWhat Cute Animal Are You?
Come on, be honest. Who saw a sheep type coming? I dunno, I was hoping I'd come out attractive like Elf but oh well.