Belated book reviews

Jul 29, 2009 20:25

Was going to review these over the weekend but fell prey to sloth and indolence, so...
War: fictional and historical )

books, history

Leave a comment

Comments 4

A Better War chocol8fiend July 30 2009, 02:58:49 UTC
I agree with the assesment of Westmorland/ Abrams.

In Westmorlands defence I would like to point out 3 advantages Abrams had.

1.) Most of his term he didnt have LBJ sitting in the white house telling him where to bomb - every night
2.) He didnt have Mcnamera as Sec of defense
3.) He had Westmorlands mistakes to study.

Reply

Re: A Better War wombat_socho July 30 2009, 12:23:04 UTC
These things are all true, but as Sorley points out, Nixon's White House was just as prone to micromanagement (in some ways) as LBJ's. I was not pleased to learn this. :(

Reply


Strongest Tribe chocol8fiend July 30 2009, 03:00:02 UTC
What were some of the mistakes of Bush, as seen by West?

Reply

Re: Strongest Tribe wombat_socho July 30 2009, 12:24:20 UTC
The two biggest ones, in West's opinion, were breaking up the Iraqi Army and trying to keep the number of troops to a minimum during the invasion and up to the Surge.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up