winners: challenge 5 (monochromatic)
First
(5 pts)
Second
(4 pts)
Third - Tie
(3 pts)
mrsdianablackw/14 votes
karinmcrw/11 votes
vamp926w/9 votes
Third - Tie
(3 pts)
Best Use of Text
(2 pts)
Mod's Choice
(1 pt)
narniacmrw/9 votes
karinmcrw/6 votes
lessrest
TALLIES:
votes / special category
♥ = # of special category votes
1
+++ - Lovely use of duplication and the softness of the icon is stunning!
+++ - because it's soft and has nice composition
++ - Lovely composition!
+ - no reason
no category votes
vamp92609/00
2
+++ - no reason
+++ - Fantastic texture use!
+ - no reason
no catgeory votes
magicallaw07/00
3
+++ - no reason
+++ - love the duplication
++ - no reason
♥♥♥
lessrest08/03
4
+++ - Contrast is great and the duplication works well
++ - no reason
++ - no reason
no category votes
rowofstars07/00
5
++ - no reason
+ - no reason
+ - no reason
no category votes
haldir_lives1304/00
6
+++ - love the text use and crop
++ - Fantastic lighting and crop. Great Text!
++ - beautiful crop
+ - no reason
+ - Great text!
+ - I love the extreme close crop on Martha, as well as the text. It's such a simple, and yet emotive icon.
+ - Stunning contrast! The text is perfect for the image and crop.
♥♥♥♥♥♥
karinmcr11/06
7
+++ - I love the blending and the crops.
+++ - no reason
++ - no reason
++ - Wonderful blending and composition, and wonderful use of text as well.
++ - The text and texture use makes the icon very emotional.
+ - no reason
+ - I like the layout (are they two different screencaps? I want to say yes, but they fit together so well it's hard to tell)
♥♥♥
mrsdianablack14/03
8
+++ - I love how simple and yet emotive it is -- the image of Rose's back pressed against the TARDIS, and the negative space, all in one shot. The black and white only adds to the mood of despair.
no category votes
othellia03/00
9
+++ - no reason
++ - no reason
++ - simple, but the placement and contrast of the characters really bring out the scene
+ - no reason
+ - unique cap and crop
no category votes
narniacmr09/00
Congratulations!
Though reasons given are listed as optional, this is a rumble and comments really are appreciated when you vote.
Challenge Six is Here!!