Winners: Challenge 6: Mod's Choice
Winners of Challenge 6 are behind the cut!
First
(5 pts)
Second
(4 pts)
Third
(3 pts)
quiddity_
w/ 18 votes
blue_emotion
w/ 17 votes
kolibrichen
w/ 14 votes
Best Cap Choice
(2 pts)
Mod's Choice
(1 pt)
veronicasleeps
w/ 5 votes
palm__tree
TALLIES:
votes / special category
♥ = # of special category votes
+ - nice crop and color
welshgirl15
01/00
+++ - no comment
+ - I can feel the fear.
♥♥
marcasite
04/02
++ - Great blending!
+ - great flowing composition
+ - no comment
mergana
04/00
+ - I love the off-center cropping and the cap choice.
n_e_star
01/00
+++ - Great colouring on the top half. the Caps work together brilliantly. And the text is perfect!
+++ - I know both were sample caps, but the juxtaposition between the two together with the coloring/desaturation is so perfect. Love the balance.
+++ - no comment
++ - The composition is fantastic and the text was a nice touch.
+ - no comment
♥
annieohhhhyes
12/01
+++ - Composition is gorgeous and text is wonderfully used.
++ - Really love the composition of this one
++ - no comment
++ - love the levels and coloring
+ - nice text use; great composition
♥
sesperia
11/01
++ - no comment
♥♥♥♥
palm__tree
02/04
+++ - beautiful crop and coloring
+++ - Gorgeous! Beautiful crop
+++ - very well cropped, good use of light
++ - stunning crop and the colouring is very beautiful
++ - red coloring really pops and the crop is amazing
++ - Eye-catching close crop and nice subtle coloring
++ - AMAZING crop and beautiful coloring
+ - no comment
♥♥♥
quiddity_
18/03
++ - no comment
++ - no comment
rowofstars
04/00
+++ - Wow! This is stunning! The bright colours are so well incorporated and the light/shadow emphasis gives the icon a lot of depth.
++ - no comment
++ - simple composition and great coloring
++ - no comment
++ - no comment
+ - no comment
+ - Negative space is perfectly used and the small lighting effect emphasizes the Tardis nicely.
+ - no comment
♥
♥ - It's a gorgeous capture- and it works so very well with the crop and the soft colouring.
kolibrichen
14/02
+++ - wonderful colouring and use of neg. space
+++ - love the negative space and texture use
+++ - It's like something from a dream.
+ - Lovely image placement & blending
+ - I love the mystical, almost poetic feeling and use of negative space
♥♥♥♥♥
veronicasleeps
11/05
NO VOTES
creativedreamin
00/00
+++ - no comment
+ - no comment
♥
magicallaw
04/01
++ - I love the translucent quality.
++ - I think that despite the business it works very well. Though I'd have like it better if Idris and the Doctor would have been better visible.
♥
ladyjfoechuckle
04/01
+++ - no comment
+++ - Beautiful coloring and the font choice is very nice!
+++ - The text and colouration work very well together. I also love the lighting.
++ - beautiful glow & use of text
++ - The lighting/coloring is fantastic, and the choice of font is perfect.
++ - no comment
+ - good use of text
+ - lovely yellow colouring and the work with the text is gorgeous
blue_emotion
17/00
++ - Lovely cropping. The centre crop works well without being boring.
jelly_head91
02/00
+++ - no comment
+ - no comment
+ - One look at it and I got all fuzzy inside; the text, the coloring, just gives it a carefree vibe.
+ - no comment
♥♥
othellia
06/02
+++ - no comment
+++ - Really like the coloring and sharpness, and let's just say I have a thing for this font.
+ - Beautiful colouring
narniacmr
07/00
NO VOTES
karinmcr
00/00
+++ - no comment
+++ - really gorgeous combination of black and white and cap pic to showcase the doctor's expression.
+++ - love the crop
+ - Stunning b/w!
+ - Great contrast.
darlingbones
11/00
Congratulations!
darlingbones submitted her icons early, so here's her other entry:
The rest of the entries have been unscreened and you can see the alternate icons here
You can view the tally board here. Feel free to check it whenever you see fit.
First
(5 pts)
Second
(4 pts)
Third
(3 pts)
quiddity_
w/ 18 votes
blue_emotion
w/ 17 votes
kolibrichen
w/ 14 votes
Best Cap Choice
(2 pts)
Mod's Choice
(1 pt)
veronicasleeps
w/ 5 votes
palm__tree
TALLIES:
votes / special category
♥ = # of special category votes
+ - nice crop and color
welshgirl15
01/00
+++ - no comment
+ - I can feel the fear.
♥♥
marcasite
04/02
++ - Great blending!
+ - great flowing composition
+ - no comment
mergana
04/00
+ - I love the off-center cropping and the cap choice.
n_e_star
01/00
+++ - Great colouring on the top half. the Caps work together brilliantly. And the text is perfect!
+++ - I know both were sample caps, but the juxtaposition between the two together with the coloring/desaturation is so perfect. Love the balance.
+++ - no comment
++ - The composition is fantastic and the text was a nice touch.
+ - no comment
♥
annieohhhhyes
12/01
+++ - Composition is gorgeous and text is wonderfully used.
++ - Really love the composition of this one
++ - no comment
++ - love the levels and coloring
+ - nice text use; great composition
♥
sesperia
11/01
++ - no comment
♥♥♥♥
palm__tree
02/04
+++ - beautiful crop and coloring
+++ - Gorgeous! Beautiful crop
+++ - very well cropped, good use of light
++ - stunning crop and the colouring is very beautiful
++ - red coloring really pops and the crop is amazing
++ - Eye-catching close crop and nice subtle coloring
++ - AMAZING crop and beautiful coloring
+ - no comment
♥♥♥
quiddity_
18/03
++ - no comment
++ - no comment
rowofstars
04/00
+++ - Wow! This is stunning! The bright colours are so well incorporated and the light/shadow emphasis gives the icon a lot of depth.
++ - no comment
++ - simple composition and great coloring
++ - no comment
++ - no comment
+ - no comment
+ - Negative space is perfectly used and the small lighting effect emphasizes the Tardis nicely.
+ - no comment
♥
♥ - It's a gorgeous capture- and it works so very well with the crop and the soft colouring.
kolibrichen
14/02
+++ - wonderful colouring and use of neg. space
+++ - love the negative space and texture use
+++ - It's like something from a dream.
+ - Lovely image placement & blending
+ - I love the mystical, almost poetic feeling and use of negative space
♥♥♥♥♥
veronicasleeps
11/05
NO VOTES
creativedreamin
00/00
+++ - no comment
+ - no comment
♥
magicallaw
04/01
++ - I love the translucent quality.
++ - I think that despite the business it works very well. Though I'd have like it better if Idris and the Doctor would have been better visible.
♥
ladyjfoechuckle
04/01
+++ - no comment
+++ - Beautiful coloring and the font choice is very nice!
+++ - The text and colouration work very well together. I also love the lighting.
++ - beautiful glow & use of text
++ - The lighting/coloring is fantastic, and the choice of font is perfect.
++ - no comment
+ - good use of text
+ - lovely yellow colouring and the work with the text is gorgeous
blue_emotion
17/00
++ - Lovely cropping. The centre crop works well without being boring.
jelly_head91
02/00
+++ - no comment
+ - no comment
+ - One look at it and I got all fuzzy inside; the text, the coloring, just gives it a carefree vibe.
+ - no comment
♥♥
othellia
06/02
+++ - no comment
+++ - Really like the coloring and sharpness, and let's just say I have a thing for this font.
+ - Beautiful colouring
narniacmr
07/00
NO VOTES
karinmcr
00/00
+++ - no comment
+++ - really gorgeous combination of black and white and cap pic to showcase the doctor's expression.
+++ - love the crop
+ - Stunning b/w!
+ - Great contrast.
darlingbones
11/00
Congratulations!
darlingbones submitted her icons early, so here's her other entry:
The rest of the entries have been unscreened and you can see the alternate icons here
You can view the tally board here. Feel free to check it whenever you see fit.