Winners: Challenge 2: Playing Dress Up
Sorry, guys, was waiting for some people to vote and then this weekend was kind of weird, but here we go, the winners of Challenge 2!
First
(5 pts)
Second
(4 pts)
Third
(3 pts)
blue_emotion
w/ 38 votes
lemonpunch
w/ 25 votes
welshgirl15
w/ 17 votes
Best Cropping
(2 pts)
Mod's Choice
(1 pt)
creativedreamin
w/ 8 votes
othellia
TALLIES:
votes / special category
♥ = # of special category votes
+ - really great use of text and image
+ - Great use of text!
♥
veronicasleeps
02/01
NO VOTES
♥♥♥♥
annieohhhhyes
00/04
+++ - The colouring and the focus on Auton!Rory's time spent waiting is just lovely.
++ - no comment
+ - I like the addition of the clock.
rowofstars
06/00
+ - Lovely coloring!
♥
magicallaw
01/01
NO VOTES
mergana
00/00
+++ - Gorgeous vibrant colours & crop
+++ - Amazing coloring, really beautiful. Bright without being too bright, saturated without being too saturated, the balance is perfect in this icon. The crop is lovely too, I focused immediately on Amy's eyes and mouth. The sharpness is perfect too!
++ - Lovely coloring and perfect crop.
++ - the crop is just perfect! the coloring and the vividness, esp of her hair, really makes the icon pop!
++ - Loooove the colours
+ - great coloring and crop
+ - Fantastic crop and lovely coloring.
+ - I like the close crop and the coloring used.
♥♥♥
marcasite
15/03
+++ - no comment
++ - Really love the image choice and placement on this
+ - the background color and lighting really make martha pop, i love the cap choice on this
♥♥♥
♥ - fantastic crop which really works with the cap, it really manages to capture and express what Martha must be feeling in those episodes!
darlingbones
06/04
+++ - negative space is gorgeous as well as the coloring
++ - wonderful coloring and great execution
++ - no comment
karinmcr
07/00
++ - I love the simplicity of the icon. It really caught my eye.
sesperia
02/00
+++ - The colouring on this is stunning and the use of centre cropping is great!
++ - gorgeous vibrant colouring
++ - Love how Amy sort of pops out from the background and very nice coloring for such a dark scene.
sourpony
07/00
NO VOTES
palm__tree
00/00
+++ - LOVE the crop, it's perfect! The coloring is so well done! It really stands out against the others!
+ - a little saturated and soft but it suits the mood of the icon
+ - it's a little too saturated, but the crop and composition is lovely
♥♥♥
spittingfish
05/03
+++ - no comment
+++ - You really captured the motion.
+++ - excellent cropping and the colouring is just gorgeous
+++ - really love the cropping and colouring of the icon
+++ - because of the colouring and cropping
++ - I love this icon, I love how it's cropped so you can't see Rory's face and I just love the picture in general.
♥♥♥♥♥♥
♥ - Very dramatic crop!
welshgirl15
17/07
NO VOTES
needtakehave
00/00
++ - Lovely clear image, and I like how the cap is skewed, it makes the icon interesting
+ - simple yet well-cropped and eye-catching
narniamcr
03/00
+++ - gorgeous use of texture and negative space
+++ - lovely composition and the three-tone coloring matching with the background is wonderful
++ - no comment
+ - wonderful work with the texture and lovely colouring
+ - The soft colours suit the image perfectly
+ - Great use of background.
+ - The colours and the negative space work very well together in the Icon.
+ - I love the creative coloring combo. The texture usage is also nice.
quiddity_
13/00
+++ - It's so bright and crisp and the texture and text is really interesting.
+++ - no comments
+++ - The negative space is expertly use, and the coloring is brilliant.
++ - the composition is amazing. I love the colors too.
++ - Gorgeous composition!
+ - Wonderful work, so colorful and bright. It makes me happy just looking at it! I'm curious what the text says though, I think it's like "hold on to your ****ery"? I'm just wondering! I love the way the coloring on Amy matches the yellow background, and the blue/white texture work really makes for an interesting composition. I'm impressed at how, despite all those textures, Amy is still the first thing you notice in the icon.
+ - negative space is one of my favourites
kawaii_chicken
15/00
+++ - really well executed icon with great colouring and concept.
+++ - Perfect texture, text, use of negative space and coloring.
+++ - great coloring and use of texture
++ - the yellow tones in the icon are all very supportive and the text use is effective
++ - pretty cap, coloring and negative space is lovely
++ - no comment
++ - Perfect text, really wonderfully done. The way part of "me" is outside of the icon looks nice and helps create the feeling that someone right outside the frame is saying those words. Lovely choice of background that goes well with the picture of Amy. I think everything in this icon ties together really well, with great result!
++ - it would look better if the texture covered the whole of the icon (the right side is distracting), but the text is great, the colouring perfect and the negative space looks great
++ - overall nice composition and coloring, the text fits in well
+ - no comment
+ - no comment
+ - Amazing use of negative space and text. Lovely coloring.
+ - coloring, texture use
lemonpunch
25/00
+++ - the coloring and crop are really splendid
+++ - Love the coloring and the space.
+++ - the tones in this image really bring out the colour in amys hair, its a little sharp but overall the crop & colour is wonderful!
+++ - no comment
+++ - Amazing colouring.
+++ - Gorgeous coloring, I just love how the greens stands out so brilliantly.
+++ - flawless, perfect coloring, very flowy and lovely
+++ - love the negative space and the colouring, natural and bright.
+++ - Beautiful bright coloring!
+++ - I like the coloring used as well as the negative space.
++ - because of the colouring
++ - such a vibrantly beautiful coloring and great use of negative space.
+ - Great coloring, love the texture and lighting.
+ - no comment
+ - Nice crop and texture use.
+ - no comment
♥♥
blue_emotion
38/02
+++ - no comment
+++ - seriously cool....have no other words
+++ - the composition is beautiful! Amy's gleeful face comined with the soft coloring makes this icon really stand out.
++ - Just lovely.
++ - Love how the repetition is done.
♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥
creativedreamin
13/08
++ - lovely crop and nice purple colouring
++ - nice and crisp, clean icon
wildalyss
04/00
+ - no comment
ladyjfoechuckle
01/00
++ - no comment
+ - love that the icon tells a story with the text and the picture. The texture is gorgeous!
kolibrichen
03/00
++ - The manip is phenomenal. I also love the coloring, it's gorgeous.
jelly_head91
02/00
NO VOTES
othellia
00/00
++ - i love the effect of the kind of "blurred" movement
++ - I LOVE the use of blur, and the b&w really dramatizes it.
++ - The blurred face shows the identity problems that the Doctor has quite nicely. I also love the B/W effect, it works very well.
++ - the repetition works wonderfully here. Going b&w was a great choice for the icon.
+ - Great use of B&W and a rather unique effect with the repeating.
+ - really interesting concept - very interesting to look at
+ - this is so interesting, the contrast could be a little brighter, but it's so creative, i love it
+ - because of the nice effect in the icon
+ - the effect here is phenomenal!
♥
acolorfulguy
13/01
NO VOTES
lessrest
00/00
NO VOTES
n_e_star
00/00
+++ - lovely use of center crop, and the soft colouring works perfectly with the chosen image.
++ - no comment
+ - pretty coloring
vamp926
06/00
Congratulations!
You can view the tally board here. Feel free to check it whenever you see fit.
First
(5 pts)
Second
(4 pts)
Third
(3 pts)
blue_emotion
w/ 38 votes
lemonpunch
w/ 25 votes
welshgirl15
w/ 17 votes
Best Cropping
(2 pts)
Mod's Choice
(1 pt)
creativedreamin
w/ 8 votes
othellia
TALLIES:
votes / special category
♥ = # of special category votes
+ - really great use of text and image
+ - Great use of text!
♥
veronicasleeps
02/01
NO VOTES
♥♥♥♥
annieohhhhyes
00/04
+++ - The colouring and the focus on Auton!Rory's time spent waiting is just lovely.
++ - no comment
+ - I like the addition of the clock.
rowofstars
06/00
+ - Lovely coloring!
♥
magicallaw
01/01
NO VOTES
mergana
00/00
+++ - Gorgeous vibrant colours & crop
+++ - Amazing coloring, really beautiful. Bright without being too bright, saturated without being too saturated, the balance is perfect in this icon. The crop is lovely too, I focused immediately on Amy's eyes and mouth. The sharpness is perfect too!
++ - Lovely coloring and perfect crop.
++ - the crop is just perfect! the coloring and the vividness, esp of her hair, really makes the icon pop!
++ - Loooove the colours
+ - great coloring and crop
+ - Fantastic crop and lovely coloring.
+ - I like the close crop and the coloring used.
♥♥♥
marcasite
15/03
+++ - no comment
++ - Really love the image choice and placement on this
+ - the background color and lighting really make martha pop, i love the cap choice on this
♥♥♥
♥ - fantastic crop which really works with the cap, it really manages to capture and express what Martha must be feeling in those episodes!
darlingbones
06/04
+++ - negative space is gorgeous as well as the coloring
++ - wonderful coloring and great execution
++ - no comment
karinmcr
07/00
++ - I love the simplicity of the icon. It really caught my eye.
sesperia
02/00
+++ - The colouring on this is stunning and the use of centre cropping is great!
++ - gorgeous vibrant colouring
++ - Love how Amy sort of pops out from the background and very nice coloring for such a dark scene.
sourpony
07/00
NO VOTES
palm__tree
00/00
+++ - LOVE the crop, it's perfect! The coloring is so well done! It really stands out against the others!
+ - a little saturated and soft but it suits the mood of the icon
+ - it's a little too saturated, but the crop and composition is lovely
♥♥♥
spittingfish
05/03
+++ - no comment
+++ - You really captured the motion.
+++ - excellent cropping and the colouring is just gorgeous
+++ - really love the cropping and colouring of the icon
+++ - because of the colouring and cropping
++ - I love this icon, I love how it's cropped so you can't see Rory's face and I just love the picture in general.
♥♥♥♥♥♥
♥ - Very dramatic crop!
welshgirl15
17/07
NO VOTES
needtakehave
00/00
++ - Lovely clear image, and I like how the cap is skewed, it makes the icon interesting
+ - simple yet well-cropped and eye-catching
narniamcr
03/00
+++ - gorgeous use of texture and negative space
+++ - lovely composition and the three-tone coloring matching with the background is wonderful
++ - no comment
+ - wonderful work with the texture and lovely colouring
+ - The soft colours suit the image perfectly
+ - Great use of background.
+ - The colours and the negative space work very well together in the Icon.
+ - I love the creative coloring combo. The texture usage is also nice.
quiddity_
13/00
+++ - It's so bright and crisp and the texture and text is really interesting.
+++ - no comments
+++ - The negative space is expertly use, and the coloring is brilliant.
++ - the composition is amazing. I love the colors too.
++ - Gorgeous composition!
+ - Wonderful work, so colorful and bright. It makes me happy just looking at it! I'm curious what the text says though, I think it's like "hold on to your ****ery"? I'm just wondering! I love the way the coloring on Amy matches the yellow background, and the blue/white texture work really makes for an interesting composition. I'm impressed at how, despite all those textures, Amy is still the first thing you notice in the icon.
+ - negative space is one of my favourites
kawaii_chicken
15/00
+++ - really well executed icon with great colouring and concept.
+++ - Perfect texture, text, use of negative space and coloring.
+++ - great coloring and use of texture
++ - the yellow tones in the icon are all very supportive and the text use is effective
++ - pretty cap, coloring and negative space is lovely
++ - no comment
++ - Perfect text, really wonderfully done. The way part of "me" is outside of the icon looks nice and helps create the feeling that someone right outside the frame is saying those words. Lovely choice of background that goes well with the picture of Amy. I think everything in this icon ties together really well, with great result!
++ - it would look better if the texture covered the whole of the icon (the right side is distracting), but the text is great, the colouring perfect and the negative space looks great
++ - overall nice composition and coloring, the text fits in well
+ - no comment
+ - no comment
+ - Amazing use of negative space and text. Lovely coloring.
+ - coloring, texture use
lemonpunch
25/00
+++ - the coloring and crop are really splendid
+++ - Love the coloring and the space.
+++ - the tones in this image really bring out the colour in amys hair, its a little sharp but overall the crop & colour is wonderful!
+++ - no comment
+++ - Amazing colouring.
+++ - Gorgeous coloring, I just love how the greens stands out so brilliantly.
+++ - flawless, perfect coloring, very flowy and lovely
+++ - love the negative space and the colouring, natural and bright.
+++ - Beautiful bright coloring!
+++ - I like the coloring used as well as the negative space.
++ - because of the colouring
++ - such a vibrantly beautiful coloring and great use of negative space.
+ - Great coloring, love the texture and lighting.
+ - no comment
+ - Nice crop and texture use.
+ - no comment
♥♥
blue_emotion
38/02
+++ - no comment
+++ - seriously cool....have no other words
+++ - the composition is beautiful! Amy's gleeful face comined with the soft coloring makes this icon really stand out.
++ - Just lovely.
++ - Love how the repetition is done.
♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥
creativedreamin
13/08
++ - lovely crop and nice purple colouring
++ - nice and crisp, clean icon
wildalyss
04/00
+ - no comment
ladyjfoechuckle
01/00
++ - no comment
+ - love that the icon tells a story with the text and the picture. The texture is gorgeous!
kolibrichen
03/00
++ - The manip is phenomenal. I also love the coloring, it's gorgeous.
jelly_head91
02/00
NO VOTES
othellia
00/00
++ - i love the effect of the kind of "blurred" movement
++ - I LOVE the use of blur, and the b&w really dramatizes it.
++ - The blurred face shows the identity problems that the Doctor has quite nicely. I also love the B/W effect, it works very well.
++ - the repetition works wonderfully here. Going b&w was a great choice for the icon.
+ - Great use of B&W and a rather unique effect with the repeating.
+ - really interesting concept - very interesting to look at
+ - this is so interesting, the contrast could be a little brighter, but it's so creative, i love it
+ - because of the nice effect in the icon
+ - the effect here is phenomenal!
♥
acolorfulguy
13/01
NO VOTES
lessrest
00/00
NO VOTES
n_e_star
00/00
+++ - lovely use of center crop, and the soft colouring works perfectly with the chosen image.
++ - no comment
+ - pretty coloring
vamp926
06/00
Congratulations!
You can view the tally board here. Feel free to check it whenever you see fit.