I really, REALLY like the look of these boots:
Off Limits Crinkle Patent Boot I tried them on today and they fit, very nicely, WITH my orthodics in. They're comfy, cute (I think so) and they're on for $39.99 right now. The only problem? I have nothing to wear with them. I'd need to buy a couple fall/winter skirts to go with them. Not that this is a problem that couldn't be fixed with some shopping, it just really tries my frugal sensibilities to buy shoes, and then need to buy clothes to go with them!!