Watching the Modrons

[waiwode]

Am I the only D&D player who never liked Planescape

Comments

[pyat]

I didn't like Planescape. I loved the idea of the setting, but the execution never appealed to me. I also didn't like the fake Dickensian cant.

[waiwode]

That latter bit is a very Viktor thing to say, I think.

Dark Sun gets the thumbs down from me too, for being Planetary Romance done wrong -- it seems every time TSR tried to break out of the faux-medieval box I was there with both thumbs down.

Well, that's not strictly true, I really did like the Green-book A Mighty Fortress. To me HR4 was the best of the lot.

Doug.

[thebitterguy]

I always thought DS was post-apoc fantasy more than Planetary Romance, but I really never had any knowledge of that stuff.

[waiwode]

It certainly has elements of both.

Doug.