Round 10 | Challenge 1 | Voting
Well, here's the voting for the first challenge of Round 10.
Eliminations: spiidfreakbarbi
Withdrawals: utaeru
Rules of voting:
- Vote for THREE icons of lesser quality to be eliminated. Also vote for TWO better quality (favorite) icon to win People's Choice or Runner-up.
When voting for icons to be eliminated, vote based on the quality & technique of the icon not on personal preferences such as character, style etc. Any vote that we feel is too biased will be void. You do not need to give a reason for your favorite vote but it is encouraged. Remember, we're also trying to help icon-makers improve their icon-making skills. Harsh comments will not be tolerated.
- Repeating your votes is fine as long as the icons you voted for elimination are not voted again for favorite or special category.
- You are not allowed to vote for your own icons, nor ask your friends to vote for you. Do not reveal your icon until after results have been posted.
- Anyone may vote, member or not. We encourage as many votes as possible.
- Also vote for Special Category. This time the special category is Best Color.
- Here is an example vote:
LESSER QUALITY ICONS:
#5 - The textures are overused and making the icon looked washed out.
#7 - The color overpowers the icon.
#1 - The text is distracting and too scratchy.
FAVOURITE ICONS:
#2 - The composition of the icon was done well and the colours are evenly balanced out.
#3 - The saturation is wonderfully chosen and the texture is well arranged.
SPECIAL CATEGORY:
#4 - The red is wonderfully soft and makes the icon seem dreamy.
- Use this form to vote:
LESSER QUALITY ICONS:
#00 - mandatory reason
#00 - mandatory reason
#00 - mandatory reason
FAVORITE ICON:
#00 - optional reason
#00 - optional reason
SPECIAL CATEGORY:
#00 - mandatory reason
- Voting ends Sunday, May 03rd
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
#01: Lujei Piche from GrimGrimoire
#02: Squirtle from Pokémon Mystery Dungeon
#03: Bubbles from Brave Fencer Mushashi
#04: Kid from Chrono Cross
#05: Rebecca Chambers from Resident Evil 0
#06: Female Fighter from Granado Espada
#07: Terra Branford from Dissidia: Final Fantasy
#08: Lylia from Valkyrie Profile 2: Silmeria
#09: Link from The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess
#10: Sora from Kingdom Hearts II
#11: Aeris and Zack from Final Fantasy VII Crisis Core
#12: Rinoa, Yuffie and Quistis from Final Fantasy VIII
#13: Aeris from Final Fantasy VII Crisis Core
#14: Main character from Persona 4
#15: Turok and a random dinosaur from Turok
#16: Trish from Devil May Cry
Voting is open until Friday to get back to our schedule.
Please be as detailed as possible, and double check your votes.
All votes are screened. All participants must vote.
Good luck!
Eliminations: spiidfreakbarbi
Withdrawals: utaeru
Rules of voting:
- Vote for THREE icons of lesser quality to be eliminated. Also vote for TWO better quality (favorite) icon to win People's Choice or Runner-up.
When voting for icons to be eliminated, vote based on the quality & technique of the icon not on personal preferences such as character, style etc. Any vote that we feel is too biased will be void. You do not need to give a reason for your favorite vote but it is encouraged. Remember, we're also trying to help icon-makers improve their icon-making skills. Harsh comments will not be tolerated.
- Repeating your votes is fine as long as the icons you voted for elimination are not voted again for favorite or special category.
- You are not allowed to vote for your own icons, nor ask your friends to vote for you. Do not reveal your icon until after results have been posted.
- Anyone may vote, member or not. We encourage as many votes as possible.
- Also vote for Special Category. This time the special category is Best Color.
- Here is an example vote:
LESSER QUALITY ICONS:
#5 - The textures are overused and making the icon looked washed out.
#7 - The color overpowers the icon.
#1 - The text is distracting and too scratchy.
FAVOURITE ICONS:
#2 - The composition of the icon was done well and the colours are evenly balanced out.
#3 - The saturation is wonderfully chosen and the texture is well arranged.
SPECIAL CATEGORY:
#4 - The red is wonderfully soft and makes the icon seem dreamy.
- Use this form to vote:
LESSER QUALITY ICONS:
#00 - mandatory reason
#00 - mandatory reason
#00 - mandatory reason
FAVORITE ICON:
#00 - optional reason
#00 - optional reason
SPECIAL CATEGORY:
#00 - mandatory reason
- Voting ends Sunday, May 03rd
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
#01: Lujei Piche from GrimGrimoire
#02: Squirtle from Pokémon Mystery Dungeon
#03: Bubbles from Brave Fencer Mushashi
#04: Kid from Chrono Cross
#05: Rebecca Chambers from Resident Evil 0
#06: Female Fighter from Granado Espada
#07: Terra Branford from Dissidia: Final Fantasy
#08: Lylia from Valkyrie Profile 2: Silmeria
#09: Link from The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess
#10: Sora from Kingdom Hearts II
#11: Aeris and Zack from Final Fantasy VII Crisis Core
#12: Rinoa, Yuffie and Quistis from Final Fantasy VIII
#13: Aeris from Final Fantasy VII Crisis Core
#14: Main character from Persona 4
#15: Turok and a random dinosaur from Turok
#16: Trish from Devil May Cry
Voting is open until Friday to get back to our schedule.
Please be as detailed as possible, and double check your votes.
All votes are screened. All participants must vote.
Good luck!