challenge 1; round 3: results
Unfortunately we must say bye to the following this week:
by gerryswenchie with -4 votes.
Thanks for participating, hope you stay around!
VOTER'S CHOICE:
by agent-ofchaos with +1 votes
MOD'S CHOICE:
by cerberusk
TALLY If your number is not listed, you did not receive any votes.
01; - = -1
02; - = -1
03; + = +1 >> VOTER'S CHOICE
04; - - = -2
05; + - - = -1
06; - - - - = -4 >> ELIMINATED
08; + + - - = 0
COMMENTS
1:
- Crop could've been done better,and the other icon just seems to be unfinished
2:
- Nice crop, but looks like there's not much done with the coloring and the text on Johnny icon doesn't go well with rest of the icon
3:
+ Crop on both icons are excellent, as well as the coloring
4:
- too much lighting in the first icon & too much going on in the BG of the second icon
- The gold coloring makes Keira's face & hair look really pixely, and the background on the Johnny icon is distracting
5:
- not much done with the icons & the crops are boring
- The icons are too simple. There wasn't anything done except changing the coloring. Though they are nice, they are the simplest among the other icons
+ Both icons are impeccably simple - the coloring is subtle, and the focus is completely on Johnny and Keira
6:
- the images look griany & the text is distracting
- The coloring on both icons is pretty washed out, and the text is unnecessary - as is the texture on the Johnny icon
- Poor coloring and text/brush is slightly blurred out
- The positioning of the brush/texture on both icons is a bit off. And there was nothing really done on the pictures. The brush/texture on the Depp icon doesn't match the picture. Maybe change the colors? The crops are nice, though
8:
- The Keira icon is almost good, but the random "k" is a distraction from the crop and texture of the icon. The Johnny icon is too sharp
- The Depp icon is a bit grainy. Great crop, though. And the "k" on the Keira one is placed awkwardly. Maybe remove it or place it somewhere else
+ I love the composition of Neira's icon & I like the simple crop of Johnny's icon
+ Love the crop on those icons
If you have any questions, feel free to ask.
by gerryswenchie with -4 votes.
Thanks for participating, hope you stay around!
VOTER'S CHOICE:
by agent-ofchaos with +1 votes
MOD'S CHOICE:
by cerberusk
TALLY If your number is not listed, you did not receive any votes.
01; - = -1
02; - = -1
03; + = +1 >> VOTER'S CHOICE
04; - - = -2
05; + - - = -1
06; - - - - = -4 >> ELIMINATED
08; + + - - = 0
COMMENTS
1:
- Crop could've been done better,and the other icon just seems to be unfinished
2:
- Nice crop, but looks like there's not much done with the coloring and the text on Johnny icon doesn't go well with rest of the icon
3:
+ Crop on both icons are excellent, as well as the coloring
4:
- too much lighting in the first icon & too much going on in the BG of the second icon
- The gold coloring makes Keira's face & hair look really pixely, and the background on the Johnny icon is distracting
5:
- not much done with the icons & the crops are boring
- The icons are too simple. There wasn't anything done except changing the coloring. Though they are nice, they are the simplest among the other icons
+ Both icons are impeccably simple - the coloring is subtle, and the focus is completely on Johnny and Keira
6:
- the images look griany & the text is distracting
- The coloring on both icons is pretty washed out, and the text is unnecessary - as is the texture on the Johnny icon
- Poor coloring and text/brush is slightly blurred out
- The positioning of the brush/texture on both icons is a bit off. And there was nothing really done on the pictures. The brush/texture on the Depp icon doesn't match the picture. Maybe change the colors? The crops are nice, though
8:
- The Keira icon is almost good, but the random "k" is a distraction from the crop and texture of the icon. The Johnny icon is too sharp
- The Depp icon is a bit grainy. Great crop, though. And the "k" on the Keira one is placed awkwardly. Maybe remove it or place it somewhere else
+ I love the composition of Neira's icon & I like the simple crop of Johnny's icon
+ Love the crop on those icons
If you have any questions, feel free to ask.