Supernatural Confession #67

Sep 02, 2011 22:07

Read more... )

Leave a comment

Comments 12

mihka_mc September 3 2011, 04:14:49 UTC
Confession 559:: Totally with you on that one!

Reply


philstar22 September 3 2011, 04:56:59 UTC
I'm confused on 555. Why would that make one hate John?

Reply

usmc75 September 3 2011, 05:00:19 UTC
How many pictures exsist of John and Deam fishing? Better yet, how many tomes do you think John took those boys fishing? Or to a baseball game?

Reply

philstar22 September 3 2011, 05:04:00 UTC
It isn't like he didn't spend any time with them. Of course he would do fun stuff with Adam. That is generally the way it works with non-custodial parents: when they show up, they take the kids to do fun stuff. They don't do the actual parenting stuff, just the fun stuff.

Honestly, I got really pissed off at the show for retconning John into an even worse father than he was in the early seasons. In the early seasons he was a flawed father who ultimately loved his children and protected them. Yes, he taught them to fight and was away a lot, but it wasn't until the later seasons where we are told that well, actually, John was never really there and Dean raised Sam.

Reply

usmc75 September 3 2011, 05:12:29 UTC
I agree hence the confession. This episode really just seemed to try to drive home that John Winchester sucked and it kinda pissed me off.

Reply


framedhim September 3 2011, 07:35:52 UTC
#555 re-inforced what a horrid father John was in my mind. My problem with this photo, concerning that particular episode, was in knowing that somewhere, his boys were left alone, while he sat there and played house for a day. John's character makes me have to ...remember it's fiction, and to not be so weird about it.

#551 I think I was more surprised to see he hadn't turned the darn thing into a shiv.

Reply


sarahk_1963 September 3 2011, 08:34:08 UTC
*snerk*

Reply


cats_eye78 September 4 2011, 04:16:44 UTC
599-- Yes please, loose the shirt. Especially if he has to make the porny face.
555-- This episode made my hatred complete. So they have to rub it in our faces that he did know how to be a decent, if largely absent, father. Where were Dean and Sam's baseball games? Huh, huh!! Bastard.
553-- I thought he looked goofy. But that judgement is made with him standing next to Sam and Dean, sooo.
551-- Secretly Sam loved the pink toothbrush. Cause Dean took the time to try to bug him.

Reply

brigid_tanner September 4 2011, 04:38:26 UTC
i think the monsters photoshopped those pics of John being a "good dad". I don't believe he was more of a father to Adam than he was to Dean and Sam.

Reply

usmc75 September 4 2011, 13:07:35 UTC
I like your #551 better than mine :)

Reply

usmc75 September 5 2011, 21:54:48 UTC

Leave a comment

Up