Apply?

[xartificallove]

If you would like to join this community so that you can post your amazing Final Fantasy icons. Please fill out the little form and post it as a comment before joining the community:

1- link to graphic journal or other
2- (optional) examples of graphics
3- (optional) would you like constructive criticism?

Please don't be offended if we do not grant you

Comments

[decomposition]

graphic community @ candy_horror

[xartificallove]

I'm going to say yes :)
First of all GIPPAL YAAAAY! I have fallen in love with your colourings, they are so dreamy! I also love the pictures you have used & I love your cropping especially in icon 3 it works really well.

The only thing I would say is maybe some people might find them a bit to dark, I don't but maybe your icon 2 is a bit on the dark side. Also some of the pictures you have used look a bit pixelly.

Due to a new rule you must have another yes from either gunshou or surmise.

Good luck :)

yes

[gunshou]

I love the cropping on 1, 3, and 4. Five could be enlivened by a more edgy crop and maybe a little more vibrancy in the colors. Two also seems a bit washed out for me, with the background blending too much into Rikku's skin and sleeve; but I get the effect you were going for there.

The faces on four and five look quite out-of-focus to me, but since my eyes are kind of bad and my monitor is old, that may not actually be true. It's something to think about, though.

[decomposition]

sorry to bother you, but your messaging settings won't let me reply. my post was rejected and you said i need to submit an application here, but i already did a while ago...?

http://community.livejournal.com/ultimatefficons/355.html?thread=4451#t4451

unless there's something else i need to do?

[gunshou]

Sorry, I didn't even see that; I thought you were applying for access, since members' posts shouldn't be moderated. I think you have to PM xartificiallove to allow you to post unmoderated; I can't switch that option for you. But go ahead and make the post again and I'll approve it.

Sorry about that!

[decomposition]

ahhh i see, alright! thank you, i'll post again then :)

[xartificallove]

Well done! You have two yes's!

Please join the community & wait for posting access.

surmise you can still give your opinion.

[surmise]

LOLL. You know I'll say yes. I've always loved your icons <3