Round Three - Challenge 1 - Voting!

[chaotic_vanity]

The following people failed to submit an icon and are eliminated from the competition. Hope you guys will still stick around and vote!
alpaca4eva firstday_icthus kairisume limmenel

Round 3 - Challenge 1 - Voting

Rules
1. Voting will be closed Monday eveningish.
2. Participants are not required to vote, but I would really appreciate it. You do not need to be a member to vote! Anonymous votes will not be counted.
3. You will be voting for THREE lesser quality icons. Do not vote based on your personal style preferences. A good rule to follow is to avoid using "I": I don't like the coloring, etc.
4. Comment to this post with your votes for the three worst icons and one favorite icon. You MUST provide a reason for the negative votes. If you don't provide a reason, I will not count your vote. While it's not required that you provide a reason for your favorite icon, I'm sure the icon-maker would appreciate it.
5. Comments are screened.

EXAMPLE VOTE:
Voting off:
#93: The icon is oversharpened.
#107: The coloring is too dark.
#65: The icon is too busy.

Favorite:
#100: The coloring is gorgeous and the text placement is perfect.



TEMPLATE:

Voting off:
#00: Reason
#00: Reason
#00: Reason

Favorite:
#00: Reason not required but appreciated.

We have 26 gorgeous icons to vote on! =) Thank you to everyone who submitted!

Please DO NOT vote based on the icon-maker's interpretation of the theme, image choice, or text choice. Vote according to icon quality.

1
2
3
4
5











6
7
8
9
10











11
12
13
14
15











16
17
18
19
20











21
22
23
24
25











26
27
28
29
30



No Icon
No Icon
No Icon
No Icon