Round 13 - Challenge 01 - Voting

[absolutelybatty]

ROUND 13 - CHALLENGE 01 VOTING - CHOCOLATE + STRAWBERRIES
And so it begins! Thank you all for all the wonderful entries! I think this is one of the highest turnouts this community has ever gotten!

Comments

[anonymous]

[absolutelybatty]

Hi and thank you for voting! Everything in your vote is fine save for your first constructive criticism vote. The first half, about the tiny text, will need to be rephrased in order for your vote to count. Please keep in mind votes must be based on technical aspects not personal preference. Thank you and if you need any assistance in rephrasing your vote, please let me know. :)

[anonymous]

[absolutelybatty]

To be perfectly clear here, the issue was with this statement: doesn't seem to have a point. It indicates that you, personally, don't think it has a point when, clearly, the icon maker did. Though there is nothing wrong with singling out that aspect and critiquing it, the phrasing needed to be tweaked to be more constructive and less personally critical (i.e. saying something along the lines of 'it seems out of place where you have positioned it and could be better placed here or here in order to unify the composition').

At any rate, thank you very much for changing your vote.

[anonymous]

[absolutelybatty]

Hi! It looks like I didn't catch this when you vote first came in, but comments about whether or not an icon fits the theme are not allowed in the constructive criticism section. If you feel you need to make a comment about it, please put it in the 'additional comments' section. Thank you!

As your vote has substance, I don't need you to come back and edit, but I will be removing that from your vote. The rest is perfectly fine though. :)

[absolutelybatty]

Closed.