Review: DW S4. 'The Poison Sky'

[tromana]

Well... talk about your big reset button ending - that didn't make sense. I KNEW the skience would bug me this week. Blowing up a portion of the atmosphere would lead to dead planet, not just clearing the gas. Also the chain reaction for igniting the whole atmosphere happened rather fast yes? It could've fizzled out y'know - would have been

Comments

[jo_mako]

Re: The Brig. I screamed in joy! Thankfully I live with Who fans or it would have been ugly. Sir Brig! >>>> All y'all!

Re: Rose microsecond. Someone pointed out that she isn't screaming 'Doctor', but 'Donna'...interestink...

Re: Romana Jr, showing up next week. THIS IS TRUFAX!

[tromana]

Re: Rose microsecond. Someone pointed out that she isn't screaming 'Doctor', but 'Donna'...interestink...

Hm... must watch again. They are similar-ish words. If it's Donna... that confuses me even more. HALP.

[jo_mako]

hollywoodgrrl apparently spotted it. And it would make sense kinda...at the of PiC, Rose looked like she knew who Donna was, and she had the sad face thing going before disappearing. I am interested in seeing where this goes...

[sneakyangel]

If Jenny doesn't have a mother's name confirmed, she's automatically Romana in my mind. In fact she's automatically Romana until proven otherwise.

Most deffinatly!!! All the Doctor/Rose shippers want her to be Rose's daughter, and a tiny part of me wants that too, but I just cannot see that happening. Romana on teh other hand, MOST DEFFINATLY!!!!

And oh how I squeed when the Doctor mentioned the Brig! So much that I missed the following lines. And again when Rose was on screen.

[tromana]

Is it next week yet?

Why did the Brig have to be stuck in Peru? When they said that I was annoyed. Still think they should have him in there somehow...

[sneakyangel]

Lol! I'm really hoping next weeks episode will be good. I'm already annoyed that I'll be watching a Martha episode on my birthday. I'll be sooo disapointed if its a cop-out. (Although Jenny being Romana's daughter would make my whole year!)

I completely missed that the Brig was in Peru. Who said that?

[tromana]

Yes, but Martha gets KIDNAPPED on your birthday and doesn't want to be there herself. Erm... I can't spin that any other ways, I'm afraid. And at least you get an episode on your birthday. The series ends a few days before mine, provided we have no break for Eurovision. Yeah. Now I'm out.

I will disappointed if it's a cop out too. After all, Susan is his Grand-daughter... so he's already a father anyway.

Colonel Mace said that the Brig was a Lord and 'stuck in Peru' after the Doctor mentioned him... I still say bring him back!

[persiflage_1]

Donna may have thwacked his arm, but she totally hugged him when he saved her from being shot by the Sontarans !

[tromana]

lol fair enough...