(no subject)
Person A
- I kind of like this week's icon. I like it a little better than person B's this week, but I like person B's a little more. I believe this person has been in the bottom a few times, too.
- At first, I voted for their icon as my least favorite, and then I switched it to Person B's instead. So I don't love their icon because I find it a little plain, but I don't think it's a bad icon. I still really like their second and dislike the coloring in the third.
- At first glance I thought I liked this icon better than the other two but when I went back to look at the voting and the image itself, the problems became more apparent.
- I actually like this week's icon. I still love the Betty one, but the Brittany one kills me. Specifically the blue teeth. Also, something about the clarity of all the icons are off.
Person B
- It's too hard to tell who is in this week's icon & it's oversharpened. I LOVE LOVE LOVE the second one (in fact that's what's saving this person). The third is okay, but a little awkward.
- Overall, I like the use of color in these three icons. It doesn't work quite as well in the first one but it's still creative and I like that. More specifically, the figure stands out too much from the background and the overall look is jagged and awkward. Also, in comparison to the other icons this challenge, the contrast is very high and that made it stand out. I love the second and the third is good.
- I don't mind the coloring - I do mind the image of the person in it - it's somewhere between I-want-you-to-be-able-to-see-what/who-it-is and I-don't-want-you-to-be-able-to-see-what/who-it-is. Their second icon shows a ton of creativity
- I just think the colors were too harsh in this week's icon. But I really love the second one and the third is good.
Voting total:
A: 4
B: 0
(obviously we didn't have all that many people judging this week. that's why these results are pretty late...I was waiting for more judges)
So we must say goodbye to:
mangofandango