Comments | thrift: ☞ icon critique meme

thrift

☞ icon critique meme

Feb 04, 2009 22:52

《ICONCRITMEME》
<
♠ reply to this post with your username and/or journal you post your icons at. along with that, post 5-12 icon samples, so everyone can give you some of their thoughts too.

♡ reply to people's ( even people that you aren't familiar with an outsider's perspective is good ) comments with critiques and opinions on their icons. ( Read more... )

privacy: public, graphics: icon, random: meme

Leave a comment

Back to all threads

januaried February 5 2009, 04:46:13 UTC

rizny

( ... )

inquisitory February 5 2009, 05:16:58 UTC

So cool! I really like your compositions, they're so interesting and diverse~ Especially 1, 4, 7 and 9, but they're all lovely!

ex_maylene942 February 5 2009, 05:31:39 UTC

you have an amazing texture sense! i myself have never been great with texture, but you truly use it well.

radarsparks February 5 2009, 05:33:13 UTC

you have pretty and neat texture use! it's inventive and i adore it especially in the eleventh, fourth, and second icons. however, in the first and seventh icon it seems a little too much.

garrus February 5 2009, 05:40:28 UTC

Your texture usage is generally really nice~ The "gaze up at the heavens" icon is stunning. But in the first icons in each row, it seems to be a bit too much and they make it hard to see what's in the icon.

thrift February 5 2009, 05:57:07 UTC

I always look forward to your entries at wordaffiliation because your texture use is always so gorgeous. The placements and use of your texture is always spot on. I love the light and fluffy feeling all your icons have, as well. ♥
Although I do agree with escorts that the texture use in the first icon is a bit heavy.

babettew54 February 5 2009, 14:56:06 UTC

You're icons are lovely. You know I'm a fangirl, so the ones with faces I recognize would be the ones I'd be most interested in. A few of these I can't read the writing, although that's probably your intent.

The ones I like the most are: Marilyn, Lex, L&C..!

ka_dono February 5 2009, 23:44:29 UTC

overall they are really good! I think some of them lost it a little with the textures like #1 and #6.
The #9,#10,#11 are so well done,and the colors are amazing!

ridsey February 6 2009, 02:54:14 UTC

i think there's a slight overuse in textures; in some, like the last on the first row, it works very well, but on the first of that row it's a little much and obscures the point or subject.

elthegeneral February 7 2009, 06:18:08 UTC

Totally luvs! I dig how stylized these are!

uglyextremity March 28 2009, 22:10:59 UTC

They aren't bad. They just seem really busy to me. I mean, you obviously have skill, but it's like you're trying to put ALL of your skills into one icon <3

Back to all threads