☞ icon critique meme

[thrift]

《ICONCRITMEME》
<
♠ reply to this post with your username and/or journal you post your icons at. along with that, post 5-12 icon samples, so everyone can give you some of their thoughts too.

♡ reply to people's ( even people that you aren't familiar with an outsider's perspective is good ) comments with critiques and opinions on their icons.

Comments

[thrift]

oxygene @ empyre

[januaried]

Wow, gorgeous coloring! I love how bright the last ones are, and #5. The second icon is good but isn't very interesting; maybe you could add a texture? And some text or something on #4? Other than that - utterly gorgeous work! *loves #11*

[inquisitory]

dude your icons are just like. akljfslajfldhajs so hot ;; nothing wrong with them that I can see, your colouring and textures and everything are so boss! LOVE IT ♥

[ex_maylene942]

i'v always loved your use of texture and color - you're really like ridiculously good at that as well as composition and cropping. i'm really unsure what to critique, to be honest, ha ha.

[radarsparks]

i really like the muted feeling your icons give off, especially the color tones in the first, second, and fifth icons. some seem a little extra dark, though, like the second one. 8o i also really like the third and eighth icons' texture use, they're not over-abundant and compliment the icon subject.

[zombieflu]

i love your texture work, it's so pretty and never looks cluttered or messy♥

[garrus]

I normally don't like dark icons all that much, but you do such a great job. *_* Whether it's stock or anime/manga or Asian celebrities, you manage to pull them all off with such sophistication. ♥

[onew]

i've always loved your icons, but sometimes they're too dark. (like #2) that doesn't stop you from being awesome, though. also, i'm forever in awe of your texture-using skills. i'd like to see more simple icons, maybe? i'm getting excited at the thought of seeing simple icons from you, lol

♥

[delicatinelity]

I love your icons. Your coloring, cropping, overall creatibity blows me away. Sometimes they are a bit too dark, but it works with the images you've got ♥

To be honest, you're one of the reasons why I went to make asian-related icons 8D

[candlejack]

Too bad we don't share many fandoms, because you have one of the BEST icon batches and I'm always hoping we'll share a fandom (other than DOGS) one day. I adore dark colouring and I think you mastered it so well. And, goddamn, your cropping is always so freaking delicious. I can't really offer any concrit because I adore your style; it's unique and recognizable, so kudos to you.

[ka_dono]

I like the coloring on #3 and #11, they are very good with the images!
the #12 has a nice crop!
In my opinion #5 would be interesting if it was brighter, maybe! the roses would give such a great contrast!;3

You're a great iconist!:D

[pamkips]

I just love your texture usage in general, color usage, cropping, it's just so inspiring. There's no critiques to give bc I personally believe your icons are already top notch~

[rayquaza]

AAHH I love your coloring and text and texture usage and and and I... love. Your icons. MY MIND, IT IS BLOWN.

I'm sorry I don't have crit. D:

[stickerbox]

omgomg you were the one who did #1, lol. i see people using it all the time and it's so pretty. :D okay i ttly love 3 for the texture/brush use. also, YOUR COLORING. YES. ♥

[gyaku]

one of my favorite icon maker ♥ i love your cropping & coloring, really. the BEST icons!

[herinia]

The composition of your icons is superb. Your crops and usage of textures make your style unique (such as the eighth sample ♥). I admire how when you are given an image that has been iconized by the others 498393485 times already, you can still make an icon out of it that looks different and distinct from the rest in a nice way. Your icons are simply...very pleasant to look at :DD