Pibgorn is about a fairy, Pibgorn, who has a crush on a church organist, who in turn has a jealous girlfriend. Said girlfriend happens to be a succubus. Problems ensue, get resolved, more problems ensue including vampires, poltergeists, time-traveling possession, dimensional rifts, super genius geeks, etc. I'm quite enjoying it. The creator, Brooke McEldowney, really knows his stuff musically, and he's been doing this strip since 2002! Absolutely HUGE archive, I've been working through it for several days and I'm only up to 2005, but I've really been enjoying it.
http://www.gocomics.com/pibgorn Our second new (to me) web comic, Jesus and Mo, portrays conversations between two apparent roommates, Jesus and Mo. It's not Mohammad, that would be profane, it's a body double. This strip is no where near as frequent updating as Pibgorn, but few are. Still, it goes back to 2005, but conveniently, the archive can be accessed as a month at a time, so it will be quicker to go through.
If you might be offended by inconsistencies being pointed out in Christianity or Islam, or quirks about unwavering belief, this might not be for you.
Here's the first page of the archive:
http://www.jesusandmo.net/2005/11/ Enjoy! At least if you so desire.